The History of Old New York Shared Tour

Exploring the Past of New York City: The Old New York Shared Tour

Taking a walk through Lower Manhattan with a guide who truly knows their stuff is one of the best ways to understand how New York City grew from a Dutch trading post into the vibrant metropolis it is today. This 2-hour small-group walking tour, priced at $300 per group of up to 8 people, offers an intimate look at some of the most historically significant sites in the city. Led by Richard Soden, the tour is especially popular—usually booked about 18 days in advance—and promises a detailed, engaging journey into NYC’s early days.

What we especially like about this experience is how it combines well-chosen stops with authentic storytelling. The guide’s insights lend context to each location, making history come alive—something that’s often missing from more generic sightseeing. Plus, the small-group format (maximum 14 participants) means you get plenty of personal attention and space to ask questions.

A potential consideration is the walking component, which requires moderate physical fitness. If you have mobility issues or prefer a bus tour, this might not be your best fit. But for those who love walking and want a deeper connection with the city’s origins, it’s a real treat. This tour is ideal for history buffs, first-time visitors eager to see the roots of Manhattan, or anyone curious about the stories behind iconic landmarks.

Key Points

• Deep historical focus: The tour explores foundational sites and stories from New York’s earliest days.
• Knowledgeable guides: Richard Soden’s insights bring history to life, enhancing your understanding.
• Small-group intimacy: Limited to 14 travelers, ensuring a personalized experience.
• Walking at a relaxed pace: Ideal for those comfortable with moderate physical activity.
• Free admission to stops: All sites visited are free of charge, maximizing value.
• Convenient locations: Begins near Bowling Green and ends at Trinity Church, close to subway stops.

The Experience in Detail: What to Expect from the Tour

Starting Point: Bowling Green and the First Impressions

The tour kicks off at 1 Bowling Green, a spot right in the heart of Lower Manhattan. Here, you’ll meet your guide and get a quick overview of what’s ahead. From the start, it’s clear this isn’t a rushed overview; it’s a thoughtfully curated journey meant to deepen your understanding of Old New York.

Stop 1: National Museum of the American Indian

Your first visit is to the site of the former Fort Amsterdam and the Custom House, now part of the Smithsonian Institute and home to the American Indian Museum. This stop provides a crucial perspective on the early inhabitants and the complex history of the land itself. The site itself is free to visit, and the museum offers a chance to connect with the indigenous peoples who lived here long before European settlers arrived.

Stop 2: Trinity Church Wall Street

Next, you’ll visit Trinity Church, the oldest surviving church in New York. Standing near the financial district, the church’s history stretches back to the late 17th century. Visitors often find the graves in the cemetery, including that of Alexander Hamilton, a key figure in American history. The church’s architecture and history are well worth the short visit, with free admission.

Stop 3: Castle Clinton National Monument

Once a fort, Castle Clinton was the main point of entry for immigrants arriving in New York before Ellis Island. The structure itself is a fascinating piece of history, and although brief, this stop helps you appreciate how crucial this site was in shaping the city’s diverse population. Entry is free, and it’s a quick but meaningful snapshot of NYC’s immigrant past.

Stop 4: Fraunces Tavern Museum

A highlight for many, this historic tavern is where George Washington bade farewell to his troops after the Revolutionary War. The building’s walls echo with stories of patriotism and colonial life. It’s a small stop, but the significance of the site makes it memorable. Admission is free, and you might find yourself imagining what it was like to be a soldier or revolutionary leader here.

Stop 5: Stone Street

Walking along Stone Street, you’ll see the first street in Manhattan to be paved—an overlooked but fascinating piece of urban history. This cobblestone lane, lined with historic buildings now hosting lively restaurants, offers a tangible link to the city’s earliest streets.

Stop 6: Wall Street

As you stroll Wall Street, you’ll learn about the origin of the renowned financial district—yes, there was indeed a wall here! This street’s history as a defensive barrier is visible in its name and early function. The guide’s stories animate the street’s evolution from a frontier outpost to the heart of global finance.

Stop 7: Federal Hall

Here, in Federal Hall, George Washington was inaugurated in 1789, making it a site of national importance. The building now serves as a museum and commemorates the birth of American government. It’s a short stop, but its historical significance makes it a must-see.

Stop 8: New York Stock Exchange and Fearless Girl

Your tour ends near the NYSE, the world’s largest stock exchange. You’ll learn about the history of this iconic building and the importance of the Fearless Girl statue facing the Exchange. The statue symbolizes gender equality and adds a modern twist to this historic site. This stop beautifully bridges the city’s past with its present.

Why This Tour Offers Great Value

While $300 might seem steep at first glance, remember that this price covers a private or small-group experience with a highly knowledgeable guide. All the stops are free to visit, so the value lies in the storytelling, insights, and the chance to walk through history with someone who knows the stories behind each site.

The tour’s moderate length and compact itinerary pack in a lot without overwhelming you, making it ideal for those who want to get a feel for Old New York in a short time. Plus, the small-group size ensures a more personalized experience, with plenty of space to ask questions and discuss the stories that resonate most with you.

The Authenticity Factor

One reviewer mentioned, “Despite the rain, it was great!” highlighting that even in less-than-perfect weather, the story-rich experience keeps visitors engaged. The guide’s insights seem to be a key part of why this tour stands out, making history approachable and relevant rather than dry facts.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

If you’re interested in history and storytelling, this tour is a perfect fit. It’s especially suited for travelers who love walking, want an authentic sense of place, and prefer small groups for more personal interactions. It’s ideal for first-timers eager to see the foundational sites of the city, or anyone curious about how New York’s past influences its present.

It might not be best if you’re looking for a quick overview or prefer guided tours that include transportation. But for those who want to connect with the city’s roots on foot, this tour offers a meaningful and memorable experience.

The Sum Up

This Old New York Shared Tour is a fantastic way to deepen your understanding of Manhattan’s historical roots. With engaging guides like Richard Soden, you’ll gain insights that turn mere sightseeing into a story-filled journey. The stops are carefully chosen for their historical importance, from colonial sites to the birthplace of American democracy, and the walking pace allows you to absorb the atmosphere comfortably.

While it’s not a tour for those who prefer minimal walking or have mobility concerns, it’s perfect for curious travelers who want an authentic, story-driven exploration. The small-group format ensures you’re seen and heard, making the experience both educational and intimate.

If you’re looking for a thoughtfully curated, informative walk through Lower Manhattan’s history, this tour delivers. It’s especially valuable for first-time visitors who want to see beyond the tourist spots and understand how the city’s past still echoes today.

FAQ

How long is the tour?
The tour lasts approximately 2 hours, covering several key sites in Lower Manhattan at a relaxed pace.

What is the group size?
The tour is limited to 14 travelers, which helps ensure a personal and engaging experience.

Are all the sites free to visit?
Yes, every stop on the itinerary—like Trinity Church, Castle Clinton, and Federal Hall—is free to enter or view.

What should I wear?
Since it’s a walking tour, wear comfortable shoes and weather-appropriate clothing. The tour operates in all weather conditions, so bring an umbrella if it looks rainy.

Is the tour suitable for children?
While not explicitly stated, the moderate walking and historical focus make it suitable for older children and teenagers interested in history.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins near Bowling Green and concludes at Trinity Church, both easily accessible via public transportation.

Embarking on this tour offers more than just sights; it offers a chance to walk through the pages of New York’s story, guided by someone who clearly loves sharing it. Whether you’re a history enthusiast or simply curious about the city’s origins, this experience is a meaningful way to connect with Old New York.