Made in Brooklyn Food Tour

Quick Overview

Imagine strolling through a neighborhood where Italian-American traditions are alive and well, far from the crowded tourist traps. That’s exactly what you get with the Made in Brooklyn Food Tour in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. For $65 per person, you’ll spend about three hours wandering local streets with a licensed guide who’s a proud Brooklyn native. The tour begins at Pastosa Ravioli on Bay Ridge Parkway and ends just a few blocks away, making it easy to incorporate into a full day of exploring.

What we love most is how this tour offers a focused taste of authentic Italian-American cuisine beyond pizza, along with storytelling from a local who clearly knows and loves his neighborhood. Plus, it’s a small-group experience, which means more personal attention and a chance to ask all those questions that pop up along the way. On the flip side, the tour’s focus on food made with meat, dairy, and gluten means it’s not suitable for all dietary restrictions—something to keep in mind if you have allergies or special diets.

This experience suits travelers who want an authentic, off-the-beaten-path glimpse into Brooklyn’s diverse cultural fabric, especially if you’re a foodie eager to discover hidden culinary gems. It’s perfect for those who appreciate local stories, hearty eats, and a walking pace that allows you to soak in the neighborhood’s vibe.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Key Points

Authentic Neighborhood: Experience Bensonhurst, Brooklyn’s ethnically diverse, Italian-American community, away from tourist crowds.
Local Guide: Tour led by a Brooklyn-native who shares personal insights and neighborhood history.
Taste Beyond Pizza: Sample Italian-American dishes other than the usual pizza and spaghetti.
Small Group: Intimate experience ideal for questions and personalized attention.
Duration & Price: 3 hours, $65, offering good value for a guided culinary walk.
Dietary Considerations: Focus on meat, dairy, and gluten, so not suitable for certain dietary restrictions.

While in New York City, here are other experiences we've covered

Exploring Bensonhurst’s Culinary and Cultural Heart

Walking into Bensonhurst feels like stepping into a lively, working-class neighborhood where Italian-American roots run deep. The Made in Brooklyn Food Tour offers a wonderful chance to see this slice of Brooklyn life through its flavors and stories.

The tour starts at Pastosa Ravioli, an old-school Italian specialty shop. Here, you get a taste of traditional pasta fillings, and the guide will likely share stories about how these local spots have survived and thrived through decades. It’s a great introduction to the neighborhood’s long-standing culinary traditions and set the tone for the tastings ahead.

What to Expect During the Tour

As you set off, your guide—whose passion and personal knowledge shine through—is eager to share Bensonhurst’s history as an immigrant hub. You’ll visit some of the neighborhood’s favorite family-run eateries and shops, each with its own story. Expect to taste a variety of Italian-American specialties, such as deli bites, homemade cheeses, or regional specialties that you might not find in more mainstream tourist spots.

While the tour doesn’t include beverages or extra food beyond tastings, it’s encouraged that you bring your own drinks—perhaps a water bottle or a coffee—since hydration helps during a walk, especially if the weather is warm.

The Neighborhood’s Unique Charm

What makes Bensonhurst particularly appealing is its ethnic diversity. As your guide shares stories, you’ll get a sense of how Italian traditions blend with other cultures, creating a neighborhood that feels both authentic and welcoming. The walls of the old shops and cafes echo centuries of community life, making it clear that food here is more than sustenance—it’s history and identity.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Food Tasting Experience

The tastings are carefully curated to highlight local favorites that have stood the test of time. You might find yourself savoring homemade ravioli, cured meats, or regional cheeses. These are not the mass-produced options you’ll find in chain stores—they are crafted with care by local artisans.

A reviewer mentioned “We loved the way the guide explained the neighborhood’s importance to Italian-American culture beyond just the food,” which shows how much value there is in understanding the background and significance of each stop.

Keen to taste more of New York City? We've looked into these other food and drink experiences

Authenticity and Local Insights

One of the tour’s standout features is the personal stories shared by your guide, a Brooklynite who’s lived in Bensonhurst for years. This insider perspective helps you appreciate why Brooklyn continues to draw people from all over the world—because of its resilient, diverse, and flavorful community.

The Practical Side

The tour is designed to be accessible and manageable—three hours long, walking at a relaxed pace, with stops for tasting and storytelling. It’s perfect for those who prefer small-group intimacy over large, noisy tours. The tour is generally available in the morning, making it a great way to start a day of Brooklyn exploration.

Considerations

While this tour offers a fantastic taste of Bensonhurst, it does have some limitations. Since it focuses on meat, dairy, and gluten-based foods**, vegans, vegetarians, or those with allergies might find it less suitable. Also, the cost of $65 is reasonable given the duration and personalized experience, but if you’re a serious foodie, you might want to budget for additional eats afterward.

Who Is This Tour For?

This experience is ideal for food lovers who want to discover Brooklyn’s Italian-American roots without the crowds. It’s perfect for history buffs interested in immigrant communities, as well as local culture enthusiasts. Because the tour emphasizes authentic neighborhood stops, it’s best suited for travelers who enjoy walking and exploring small, characterful shops.

If you’re traveling with older children or teenagers who appreciate good food and stories, they’ll likely enjoy the engaging narrative and tastings. However, children under 13 might find the pace or content less engaging.

The Sum Up

The Made in Brooklyn Food Tour offers a genuine taste of Bensonhurst’s Italian-American identity, combining delicious local bites with insider stories from a proud Brooklyn native. It’s a well-balanced experience that gives you more than just food—it’s a cultural journey. You’ll leave with new knowledge, a full belly, and a deeper appreciation for Brooklyn’s diverse neighborhoods.

This tour stands out as a value-rich way to explore Brooklyn’s culinary and cultural heritage on foot, especially for those seeking an authentic, off-the-beaten-path experience. It’s especially well-suited for foodies, history lovers, and curious travelers eager to see a neighborhood through the lens of its most beloved dishes.

In short, if you want a personal, flavorful look into Brooklyn’s Italian-American community, this tour will satisfy your appetite for both good stories and great eats.

FAQ

What is the price of the tour?
The tour costs $65 per person, offering a good value for a three-hour small-group guided experience.

Where does the tour start?
It begins in front of Pastosa Ravioli at 1635 Bay Ridge Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11204, near the 71st Street D line station.

How long is the tour?
The walk lasts approximately three hours, usually in the morning, providing a relaxed pace to enjoy the neighborhood.

What is included in the price?
You get tastings of Italian-American specialties (excluding pizza), a licensed guide, and insights from a local Brooklyn guide.

Are beverages included?
No, beverages are not included, but you are encouraged to bring your own drinks.

Is this tour suitable for children?
It’s best for children over 13, as the content and pace are geared towards adult or older teenage audiences.

Are dietary restrictions accommodated?
Because the focus is on meat, dairy, and gluten, this tour isn’t suitable for those with specific food allergies or vegan/vegetarian diets.

What should I bring?
Bring water or drinks to stay hydrated during the walk.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, making it easy to plan flexibly.

Final Thoughts: The Made in Brooklyn Food Tour offers a genuine, flavorful, and insightful way to explore Brooklyn’s ethnic neighborhoods, culinary traditions, and local culture. Whether you’re a keen foodie or a curious traveler, it’s an experience that rewards you with both hearty tastes and memorable stories.