New York City: Catacombs by Candlelight offers a rare glimpse beneath the streets of Little Italy at the Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral, where over 200 years of history are buried. For $38 per person, you’ll spend about 90 minutes wandering through walled cemeteries and the only active Catholic catacombs in NYC, led by guides who are eager to share their knowledge and stories. The experience is perfect for those interested in historic cemeteries, church architecture, and the stories of notable Americans laid to rest in these underground vaults.
What we love most is the exclusive access to sections normally off-limits to visitors and the atmosphere created by candlelight—it makes the experience feel intimate and a bit mysterious. Plus, guides who are both informative and personable make the tour engaging, turning history lessons into stories that stick with you long after. However, keep in mind that the tour involves stairs and isn’t fully wheelchair accessible, so those with mobility issues may want to consider that.
This tour is best suited for history buffs, architecture lovers, or anyone curious about NYC’s Catholic roots and the prominent figures buried here. It’s also a good choice for travelers who enjoy guided storytelling and want a unique, quieter experience away from busy streets. If you like exploring hidden corners of the city and hearing stories about notable Americans like the Delmonico family or Civil War generals, this tour might be just right for you.
Key Points
- Exclusive access to off-limits areas and two private cemeteries
- Engaging guides who are knowledgeable and funny
- Historical insights into prominent New Yorkers buried on site
- Atmosphere enhanced by candlelight for a memorable experience
- Duration of 1.5 hours makes it a manageable and focused tour
- Not wheelchair accessible due to stairs, and not suitable for those over 80
An In-Depth Look at the Catacombs by Candlelight Tour
What Is This Tour About?
This tour takes you beneath the Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral—a historic landmark in Little Italy—to explore the catacombs and cemeteries that are typically closed to the public. For more than two centuries, this underground network has been the final resting place for a tapestry of prominent Americans, including bishops, civil war figures, industry magnates, and influential local families like the Delmonico.
The experience is described as a “brilliant and very informative” journey into the past, with guides like Ronnie or Dan bringing the stories of those buried here alive through humor and thorough knowledge. It’s a rare opportunity to walk through areas that hold the weight of history and tradition, all illuminated by candlelight, creating a mood that’s both reverent and slightly haunting.
The Itinerary and Highlights
Meeting Point: The tour begins at 266 Mulberry Street, a central spot in Little Italy. From there, your guide will lead you through the church grounds, into areas normally off-limits. Expect to walk through two cemeteries, each with its own story—one dating back to the Civil War era, and the other a vault of elite Americans.
Main Attractions:
– The Catacombs themselves are the highlight—an underground maze where Bishops such as Bishop John Connolly rest alongside businesspeople and political figures like the Delmonico family, famous for their restaurant empire.
– You’ll see where Civil War general Thomas Eckert is buried and learn about the people who shaped New York’s development over the centuries.
– You also get a glimpse into the church’s history, from land acquisition stories to its defensive role against Protestant attacks, as one reviewer pointed out, making the tour both spiritual and historical.
What’s Unique?
The tour’s candlelight setting adds a layer of mystery and intimacy, giving a sense of what it might have been like to be amongst the dead, with the soft flickering shadows playing on stone vaults. Plus, the small group size ensures you get plenty of opportunity to ask questions and hear entertaining anecdotes.
Guide Quality and Atmosphere
The reviews are full of praise for the guides, who are described as passionate, knowledgeable, and often funny. One reviewer raved about Lee, who kept everyone engaged with his entertaining storytelling, while others highlighted guides like Ronnie and Jimme for their warm hospitality and wealth of facts.
The atmosphere, as many travelers note, is serene yet haunting, perfect for those who appreciate a quiet moment of reflection amid history’s echoes. The candles and dim lighting evoke a mood that’s much more captivating than just reading about it in a book.
More Great Tours NearbyPractical Details: What to Expect
The tour lasts about 1.5 hours, with most sessions available in the morning or afternoon. Check-in happens at 266 Mulberry Street, but remember, this is not the same as the famous St. Patrick’s Cathedral on Fifth Avenue—this is the lesser-known, historic basilica on Mulberry.
Participants are encouraged to wear comfortable shoes as you’ll be walking on uneven surfaces and stairs. The tour is wheelchair accessible only to a degree—there is one flight of stairs to reach the catacombs, making it unsuitable for wheelchair users or those over 80. Also, as a sign of respect, visitors are asked to refrain from video recordings, and attire should be weather-appropriate.
The tour includes tea lights to enhance the mood, but gratuities are not included, so you might want to tip your guide if you enjoyed the experience.
The Value of the Experience
At $38, this tour offers a remarkable value considering the unique access, the storytelling, and the historic significance. For lovers of history and architecture, it’s a chance to step into a living museum of NYC’s Catholic past. Several reviews praise guides like Dan and Leo for their passion and storytelling, which transform what could be a simple walk into a memorable lesson.
Authenticity and Audience
This experience is best for history enthusiasts, architecture fans, and travelers seeking a peaceful escape from Manhattan’s busier spots. Since it’s an active religious site, visitors should be respectful and expect a reverent atmosphere. It’s not suitable for those with mobility issues or young children over 80, but many adults find the experience both educational and emotionally moving.
Why You Should Consider This Tour
This experience isn’t just about cemeteries; it’s about understanding the stories of people who built and shaped New York. The guides’ storytelling turns tombstones into tales of ambition, faith, and conflict. The atmosphere, created by candlelight, makes it feel like stepping back in time, and the sense of exclusivity—access to areas normally hidden—adds a special touch for history buffs or curious travelers alike.
If you’re looking for a quiet, meaningful experience that combines history, architecture, and spirituality, this tour delivers on all fronts. It will appeal most to those who enjoy learning stories, exploring hidden places, and experiencing the city’s deeper layers beyond the usual tourist sites.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the tour suitable for children?
While the tour is generally appropriate for most adults, it involves walking on uneven surfaces and stairs, so children over 80 or those with mobility issues might not be comfortable.
How long is the tour?
The tour lasts approximately 1.5 hours, making it a manageable experience that fits well into a day of sightseeing in NYC.
Do I need to bring anything?
Comfortable shoes are essential, and weather-appropriate clothing is advisable. Bringing some cash for tips is also recommended, as gratuities are not included.
Can I record videos during the tour?
No, video recording is not allowed, so you can focus on soaking in the atmosphere and stories without distraction.
Is the tour wheelchair accessible?
Partially. The tour is not fully wheelchair accessible due to stairs—specifically, one flight leading into the catacombs.
What should I wear?
Dress comfortably, as you’ll be walking on uneven surfaces. No shorts or sleeveless shirts, respecting the reverent environment of the church and cemeteries.
Are there bathrooms nearby?
This information isn’t explicitly provided, so plan accordingly before the tour begins.
What kind of guides lead the tour?
Guides are described as passionate, knowledgeable, and entertaining, often adding humor to their storytelling, which helps keep the experience lively.
Is this tour suitable for non-Catholics or travelers of other faiths?
Absolutely. The tour is about history and architecture—it’s not a religious service or ceremony—so everyone can enjoy the stories and sights.
How do I find the meeting point?
Check in at 266 Mulberry Street, at the corner of Mulberry and Jersey Street. It’s easy to access from nearby neighborhoods, especially Little Italy.
In the end, this tour offers a fascinating, respectful look into New York City’s Catholic heritage—a hidden layer of history that many travelers miss. Whether you’re a history buff or just curious about the stories beneath the city, the candlelit atmosphere and expert storytelling make this a memorable outing. It’s a perfect way to connect with the city’s past in a quiet, reflective setting—an experience worth considering if you’re in the area.
You can check availability for your dates here: