NYC: Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos.

Imagine an evening where you combine the thrill of live music, the camaraderie of singing along, and the indulgence of top-notch steak and seafood — all in a secret, underground NYC venue. For just $59 per person, you gain access to a four-hour experience that’s as lively as it is refined, set inside the legendary Hunt and Fish Club, tucked away inside the AKA Times Square Hotel. This isn’t just another dinner show; it’s the longest-running dueling pianos event in New York City history, offering a unique blend of entertainment and cuisine that keeps guests coming back.

What we love most about this experience is the vast selection of songs — thousands of requests mean no two nights are alike, and the intimate, exclusive atmosphere gives it a special, almost clandestine feel. The second is the quality of the food and drink; from designer burgers to craft cocktails, everything promises to satisfy your palate. However, a consideration worth noting is the $40 minimum food and beverage requirement per guest, which can add up if you’re not planning to indulge. This experience is best suited for those who enjoy lively, interactive nights out, appreciate good food, and want to experience NYC’s vibrant entertainment scene in a more intimate setting.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Key Points

Exclusive Venue: Secret underground showroom at the Hunt and Fish Club inside the Times Square area.
All-request music: With thousands of songs, the show is always different and highly interactive.
Gourmet dining: Famous BREAD, designer burgers, and crafted cocktails elevate the experience.
Cost & value: $59 covers four hours of entertainment, with a $40 minimum food/beverage spend, plus optional gratuities.
Age restriction: Not suitable for children under 16.
Flexible booking: Cancel up to 24 hours in advance with a full refund, with options to reserve and pay later.

While in New York City, here are other experiences we've covered

A Closer Look at the Experience

The Venue and Setting

The event takes place in a hidden underground showroom within the Hunt and Fish Club, a top-rated NYC steak and seafood restaurant. This adds a sense of exclusivity and adventure, as you’d check in at the host stand and then descend into a cozy, lively space that feels like a speakeasy for music lovers. The venue’s reputation for five-star dining is well-earned, with many reviews praising their “famous” bread and exquisite menu that complements the high-energy show.

The Show: Dueling Pianos Like No Other

This isn’t just a concert; it’s a participatory, rock ‘n’ roll sing-along party. The performers, known for their talent and charisma, take requests from a vast song catalog. As one guest remarked, “The best dueling pianos show in the USA, with a menu that’s just as impressive,” emphasizing the high quality of both entertainment and cuisine.

The performers’ ability to ad lib and engage creates a night full of laughter and spontaneous fun. Since “never the same show twice” is a key feature, you might find yourself requesting everything from classic rock to pop hits, with the performers happily accommodating. This makes the event ideal for groups looking for a lively, interactive experience that’s more personalized than a typical dinner.

More Great Tours Nearby

Food and Drink

The restaurant’s reputation for chef-crafted cocktails, designer burgers, and legendary bread adds significant value. The menu is designed to match the energy of the show, with enough options to satisfy diverse tastes. The $40 food and beverage minimum encourages you to indulge, but it’s worth considering whether you’re planning to order enough to meet it — or if you prefer to keep things light and just enjoy a drink or two.

While in New York City, here are other experiences we've covered

Timing and Logistics

Seating begins at 7 pm, with the show starting at 8:30 pm — a smart choice to give you ample time to enjoy your meal beforehand. The 4-hour duration means you’ll have plenty of time to relax, eat, and sing. The tickets are held at will call, which simplifies entry, and the small group size (only 50 tickets available) ensures a more intimate, engaging experience.

Cost Analysis and Overall Value

For $59, you’re paying for more than just entry — you’re investing in an evening of top-tier entertainment, great food, and a memorable atmosphere. The additional gratuity for song requests and the service charge (20%) on food and drinks are typical for NYC dining, but they do add to the overall cost. Still, many guests find the quality of the experience to be well worth the expense, especially considering the uniqueness of the event.

Who Will Love It?

This experience is perfect for music-loving couples, group celebrations, or anyone eager to enjoy NYC’s nightlife with a twist. It’s especially suitable if you’re seeking a more exclusive, less touristy activity that combines food, fun, and live entertainment in a setting that feels both lively and intimate.

Final Thoughts

This dueling pianos evening offers a rare blend of high-energy entertainment and exceptional dining in a setting that’s as secret as it is special. With thousands of songs at your request, you’re guaranteed a personalized, lively show that’s different every time. The venue’s exclusivity and the quality of the food make it stand out from more conventional dinner shows.

While the $40 minimum spend might seem steep for casual diners, most guests agree that the ambiance, talented performers, and food quality justify the price. It’s an experience best suited for those who love singing along, enjoy a vibrant social scene, and want to see a unique side of NYC’s nightlife.

If you’re looking for a fun, interactive night in the heart of Times Square that promises laughter, great food, and live music, this is a top choice. Just be ready to sing, smile, and maybe even dance along.

FAQ

Is this experience suitable for children?
No, it’s not suitable for children under 16 due to the lively atmosphere and adult-themed humor.

How long is the show?
The event lasts approximately 4 hours, starting with seating at 7 pm and the show kicking off at 8:30 pm.

What is included in the ticket price?
Your ticket grants you reserved table seating, access to the all-request dueling pianos show, and the opportunity to enjoy the restaurant’s famed menu and drinks.

What are the payment options on the day?
You’ll need a credit card or cash to cover the $40 minimum food and beverage spend plus any gratuities or service charges added at the restaurant.

Can I cancel my reservation?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, providing you with flexibility if your plans change.

Is there a dress code?
While not explicitly stated, the setting and menu suggest casual to smart casual attire is appropriate for the venue.

How do I request songs?
Requests are made during the show, and performers are happy to accommodate a wide range of musical tastes from their extensive catalog.

This dueling pianos experience offers a lively, engaging, and delicious night out in NYC. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a memorable evening, it’s an event that balances great food with energetic entertainment — a true NYC treat.