If you’re craving a taste of the Roaring Twenties without leaving Manhattan, The Great Gatsby musical at the Broadway Theatre offers a captivating journey into F. Scott Fitzgerald’s iconic world. With a ticket costing around the price of a nice dinner for two, the 2-hour-and-30-minute show promises dazzling costumes, lively singing, and energetic dance routines that vividly recreate the Jazz Age.
What we love most are the extravagant set designs that truly transport you back to the 1920s – from the lavish parties to the opulent mansions, the stage is a feast for the eyes. Plus, the performances by Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada bring characters to life with both charisma and depth, making the story feel fresh yet true to its era.
One potential consideration is that this show is recommended for guests aged 10 and up, so families with very young children might want to plan accordingly. Also, the experience is best enjoyed with a basic understanding of English—though reviews note that even non-fluent speakers find the spectacle worthwhile.
This musical suits travelers who appreciate music, dance, and high-quality stagecraft, and those looking for an evening of genuine Broadway entertainment. It’s especially a good pick for literature lovers wanting to see Fitzgerald’s classic brought to vivid life on stage.
Key Points

- Spectacular production with elaborate 1920s sets and costumes
- Engaging performances by Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada
- Good value for a Broadway musical, considering the quality
- Family-friendly but not suitable for children under 10
- Duration of 2 hours 30 minutes, including an intermission
- Booking process is straightforward, just present your ticket at the Broadway Theatre
An Honest Look at The Great Gatsby on Broadway

When planning a night out in New York City, catching a Broadway show is often top of the list. The Great Gatsby musical offers a unique twist on the classic novel—combining storytelling with vibrant music and dance routines. The theatre itself is conveniently located in the heart of Manhattan, making it easy to combine with dinner or a stroll through Times Square beforehand.
Planning more time in New York City? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
What to Expect When You Book Your Ticket
Once you’ve secured your ticket, all you need to do is present it at the Broadway Theatre entrance. No complicated transportation arrangements—just show up, and you’re in for a treat. The show lasts about two and a half hours, including a brief intermission, so plan to arrive a little earlier to settle in comfortably.
The Set and Costume Design
From reviews, what immediately stands out is the stunning set design. The production team has gone all out to conjure the glamour and excess of the 1920s. Expect ornate, eye-catching backdrops that evoke the grandeur of East Egg and West Egg estates. The costumes are equally opulent, with flapper dresses, tuxedos, and vintage accessories that add authenticity and sparkle to each scene.
The Performances
Jeremy Jordan’s portrayal of Jay Gatsby is both charismatic and nuanced, capturing the allure and mystery of Fitzgerald’s most famous character. Eva Noblezada’s Daisy Buchanan conveys a mixture of charm and vulnerability. Reviewers frequently mention the cast’s talent, noting that even those who struggle with English find themselves swept up in the energy and emotion of the show.
More Great Tours NearbyMusic and Dance
The musical score, composed by a talented team, blends jazz-era tunes with contemporary flair, making the story accessible and lively. The choreography by Dominique Kelley keeps the pace brisk and engaging, with some reviewers calling it “a fantastic show” filled with “captivating dancing and singing.”
- 9/11 World Trade Center Walking Tour with Museum Tickets
- New York City: American Museum of Natural History Ticket
- Amish Farm and House 1-Day Tour From Washington D.C.
- 9/11 Memorial & Ground Zero Tour with Optional Museum Entry
- A Complete Unknown Movie Sites Private Tour
- Best of NYC: Big Apple Magical Lights & Broadway Guided Tour
Authenticity and Atmosphere
What we appreciate is how the production captures the spirit of the 1920s without feeling outdated. The energy is lively, yet there’s a sense of longing and romance that echoes the novel’s themes. Multiple reviews highlight the “incredible atmosphere,” and some even mention that the experience feels “magical,” even for those who aren’t fluent in English.
Considerations and Tips
While the show is highly praised, a few things to keep in mind:
- Photography and filming are not allowed inside, so bring your camera or phone for photos beforehand.
- The show is best suited for guests aged 10 and up, so families with very young children might want to consider other options.
- Expect a full theatrical experience—this isn’t just a reading of the book but a lively, visually spectacular adaptation.
Price and Value
A ticket for this show generally offers good value, considering the quality of performances and production design. Broadway tickets can be pricey, but the combination of top-tier acting, elaborate sets, and memorable music makes it a worthwhile investment for fans of musicals or classic American literature.
Who Should See It?
If you’re a fan of musicals, history, or literature, you’ll likely find this show both entertaining and meaningful. It’s perfect for those who enjoy a well-produced spectacle with a touch of nostalgia, and it appeals to both Broadway aficionados and newcomers alike.
Final Thoughts

For travelers seeking a night of authentic Broadway entertainment with a 1920s flair, The Great Gatsby musical hits the mark. It offers a visually stunning, musically lively performance that captures the glamour and allure of Fitzgerald’s world.
While it’s not a casual, quick experience, the 2.5-hour show is packed with dazzling costumes, captivating performances, and a soundtrack that keeps your toes tapping. It’s an excellent choice if you’re looking for a lively, immersive show that lets you step into a different era—even if only for a few hours.
Whether you’re a literary enthusiast, a lover of dance and music, or simply seeking a memorable night in New York City, this production offers a genuinely fun, beautifully staged experience. Just remember to book in advance, arrive early, and keep your camera stashed away during the performance.
FAQ

Is this show suitable for children?
Yes, it is recommended for guests 10 and up. Children under 4 will not be admitted, so it’s best suited for older kids and teenagers.
How long does the show last?
The entire experience lasts approximately 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Are tickets easy to purchase?
Yes, you can book tickets in advance and simply present your ticket at the Broadway Theatre entrance.
What should I bring?
Just your ticket and a valid ID, such as a passport or ID card. Photography inside the theatre is not allowed, so leave your selfie sticks at home.
Is the show in English?
Yes, the performance is in English, but reviews suggest even non-fluent speakers can enjoy the spectacle.
Can I buy food or drinks at the theatre?
Food and drinks are not included in the ticket price but are available for purchase at the venue.
What’s the best way to get to the Broadway Theatre?
The theatre is centrally located in New York City, and you can easily reach it via subway or taxi.
Why should I see this show?
Because it’s a richly staged, energetic tribute to one of America’s most beloved novels, featuring talented actors and eye-popping costumes that make the story come alive.
In summary, The Great Gatsby musical on Broadway offers a lively, beautifully crafted experience that captures the spirit of the Jazz Age. It’s perfect for those wanting a memorable evening with top-notch performances and stunning visuals—ideal for literature buffs, musical lovers, or anyone eager to enjoy a slice of 1920s glamour in the heart of New York City.
You can check availability for your dates here:More Tour Reviews in New York City
More New York City experiences we've covered
- NYC: Hell’s Kitchen the Musical on Broadway
- New York: Harlem Tour and Sunday Gospel Mass
- New York: Holiday Lights Tour with Rockefeller Tree
- NYC: Coney Island Nostalgia Tour
- NYC: Jonathan Groff in Just In Time on Broadway
- Niagara Falls from NYC One-Day Private Trip by Car
- NYC: Skip-the-Line SUMMIT One Vanderbilt Guided Tour
- The Beatles in NYC Private Walking Tour
- Secrets of Hudson Yards and the Edge: A walking tour
- New York City: Signature Dinner Cruise on the Eternity
- NYC: 9/11 Memorial, Wall Street, and Seaport Guided Tour
- NYC: Private Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride
