Experience the Spooky Side of St. Augustine: Old Jail After Dark Paranormal Investigation

If you’ve ever been curious about the supernatural, or simply enjoy a good ghost story, the Old Jail After Dark Paranormal Investigation in St. Augustine offers an engaging way to explore one of America’s most haunted sites. Priced at $106 per person for an immersive 2.5-hour adventure, this tour combines history, mystery, and hands-on ghost hunting in a setting that’s part history lesson, part supernatural adventure.
What makes this experience stand out? First, you’ll get personalized guidance from expert guides, who share their knowledge of the jail’s dark past and teach you techniques for detecting paranormal activity. Second, you’ll actually use the latest ghost-hunting equipment, making it more than just listening to ghost stories—it’s a real chance to try your hand at uncovering spirits yourself.
A couple of things to keep in mind: the tour departs just before midnight, which is perfect for setting a spooky, after-hours mood, but it’s not suited for children under 13. Also, since the group size is limited to just 8 participants, you’ll enjoy a more intimate, less crowded experience. This tour is ideal for history buffs, paranormal enthusiasts, or anyone who loves a bit of thrill mixed with storytelling.
You can check availability for your dates here:Key Points

- Authentic Paranormal Experience: Participate in a real ghost investigation with guides trained to help you understand phenomena.
- Hands-On Equipment Use: Get practical with the latest tools and traditional ghost-hunting gear, including your smartphone.
- Historical Context: Learn about the jail’s dark past, including its 8 hangings and the conditions that led to its closure in 1953.
- Small Group Setting: Limited to 8 guests for a more personal and focused experience.
- Expert Guidance: Guides share proven techniques and insights to prepare you for strange phenomena.
- Timing: Tours start just before midnight, ideal for night-time spookiness.
Planning more time in St Augustine Florida? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
Exploring the Old Jail After Dark Paranormal Investigation

Step into the shadowy corridors of the Old Jail in St. Augustine, a building infamous for its dark history and reputation for paranormal activity. This experience is as much about the storytelling as it is about the thrill of the unknown. Guided by knowledgeable experts, you’ll learn about the many legends and tales of ghostly encounters that have become part of the jail’s lore.
The History Behind the Haunted Walls
The Old Jail was closed in 1953 due to deplorable conditions and cruelty inflicted on inmates. It’s a place where injustice and tragedy linger—eight hangings took place here, and many other unnatural deaths are rumored. These dark events set the stage for the paranormal activity that many visitors and investigators have reported over the years.
What To Expect on Your Investigation
The tour begins with guides sharing techniques and tips to help you recognize and interpret strange phenomena. Expect an educational yet thrilling introduction, giving you confidence to use ghost-hunting equipment effectively.
You’ll be provided with, or encouraged to bring, your own devices—smartphones are especially useful as they serve as all-in-one ghost-hunting tools. Not only can you capture photographs of strange apparitions, but your phone’s audio recorder can pick up EVP (Electronic Voice Phenomena), which many guests find fascinating.
Once equipped, the small group of up to 8 guests will move through the jail, exploring its most active areas. The guides are skilled at helping you interpret any unusual noises, flickering lights, or cold spots you might encounter. As one reviewer noted, “We definitely captured some unexplained activity, heard disembodied voices with our own ears, and got responses to our questions.”
More Great Tours NearbyThe Experience: What You Might Encounter
Guides prepare you to expect strange sensations, sounds, or visual phenomena, which they help you distinguish from logical explanations. Some guests have reported good vibes and positive encounters, while others remain more cautious. A common theme in reviews: many feel a sense of connection or reassurance from the spirits, especially since the guides emphasize a respectful approach.
The Educational Component
After your investigation, guides will help you analyze your findings, ruling out natural causes and discussing potential paranormal explanations. This step helps make the experience more meaningful, especially for those new to ghost hunting.
Authenticity & Value
The small group setting, expert guidance, and modern equipment all contribute to the value of this tour. For just over two hours, you get an interactive, personalized experience that’s more than just listening to ghost stories—it’s about trying to see, hear, and feel the spirits for yourself.
What Other Travelers Say
Reviewers emphasize the guides’ knowledgeable and friendly demeanor. One traveler said, “The guides were very knowledgeable about the history of the jail, and there was lots of activity throughout the facility,” highlighting how well the guides blend storytelling with paranormal investigation. Others mention the thrill of capturing disembodied voices and relevant responses, making the experience memorable and engaging.
Practical Details and Tips

Meeting Point & Timing: The tour begins just before midnight at the entrance to the Old Jail, making it perfect for an after-dark adventure. Since the tour departs at this late hour, it creates an authentic spooky atmosphere.
What to Bring: Your cell phone, ideally fully charged, as it’s your most versatile ghost-hunting tool. If you have personal ghost-hunting devices, you’re encouraged to bring those, too.
Group Size & Atmosphere: With only 8 guests maximum, you’ll enjoy a cozy, interactive environment. Guides are attentive and eager to help you interpret any phenomena.
Cost & Value: At $106 per person, the tour is a good investment if you’re interested in paranormal activity, small-group interaction, and a combination of history with a spooky edge. Given the personalized guidance and equipment use, many find it worth the price.
Suitability: Best suited for those over 13, especially if you’re curious about the supernatural or love stories connected to haunted sites. It’s perfect for adventurous travelers who want to experience something truly different in St. Augustine.
More About the Experience

This tour is not just about seeing ghosts; it’s about understanding the history and lore that make the Old Jail so compelling. You’ll learn about the cruelties and tragedies that took place here, which some believe keep restless spirits lingering. The guides’ explanations about paranormal techniques add an educational layer that enhances the overall experience.
On top of that, the small group size ensures the experience feels intimate and personal. You won’t be lost in a crowd, which often makes ghost tours less immersive. Instead, you’ll get ample opportunity to ask questions, share your impressions, and even compare notes with fellow enthusiasts.
The Atmosphere
The late-night start time adds a layer of authenticity and thrill. As darkness falls, the jail’s creaky corridors and shadowy cells evoke a sense of otherworldliness. Many reviews mention a positive, almost uplifting vibe from spirits in the jail, which can be quite reassuring for those open to paranormal encounters.
Who Will Love This Tour?
Travelers who enjoy history and storytelling will appreciate the detailed background guides share. Those eager to use ghost-hunting tech will find the hands-on approach exciting, especially since many have reported capturing unexplained voices and phenomena. The small group size makes it ideal for those who prefer a more personal and less scripted experience.
Summary: Is It Worth It?

For anyone interested in the supernatural, the Old Jail After Dark Paranormal Investigation offers a well-rounded, authentic experience. It combines educational insights, hands-on equipment use, and a historic setting to create an engaging adventure. The guides’ knowledgeable approach and the modern tech available make this a compelling choice for curious travelers who want more than just ghost stories.
While it’s not a tour for families with young children or those looking for a casual sightseeing experience, it’s perfect for groups who crave a thrilling, meaningful encounter with the mysterious side of St. Augustine.
Frequently Asked Questions

Is this tour suitable for children?
No, it’s designed for guests 13 and older, due to the late hour and potentially intense nature of the investigation.
What should I bring?
Your fully charged cell phone is highly recommended, as it serves as your main ghost-hunting device. Personal ghost-hunting gadgets are also welcome.
How long does the tour last?
The investigation lasts approximately 2.5 hours, starting just before midnight.
What is included in the price?
The fee covers the guided paranormal investigation, training on ghost-hunting tools, and the use of modern and traditional equipment.
Is the experience accessible?
While specific accessibility details aren’t provided, the tour involves moving through the jail’s interior, which may have uneven surfaces. It’s best to contact the provider if you have specific needs.
Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the tour, allowing you flexibility if your schedule shifts.
What makes this tour different from other ghost tours?
This is a true investigation rather than just a storytelling walk. You’ll actively participate in the hunt, with expert guides helping you interpret phenomena and use equipment.
Final Thoughts

The Old Jail After Dark Paranormal Investigation in St. Augustine offers a unique blend of history, mystery, and modern ghost-hunting techniques. It’s ideal for those who want a personalized, hands-on experience in a genuine haunted setting. The guides’ knowledgeable approach and the opportunity to use state-of-the-art equipment elevate it beyond a typical ghost tour.
If you’re curious about the supernatural and enjoy a good story with real investigation tools in hand, this tour will likely provide memorable moments—and maybe even some unexplained surprises. It’s a perfect choice for adventure-seekers, history buffs, or anyone craving a night of spooky fun with a respectful and educational twist.
To sum it up, for a genuinely immersive and interactive paranormal experience, the Old Jail After Dark tour offers excellent value. It’s best suited for those who appreciate detailed storytelling, expert guidance, and the thrill of hunting spirits in a storied historic site. Whether you’re visiting St. Augustine for a weekend or looking for a unique night activity, this tour promises a memorable peek into the mysterious side of this charming town.
You can check availability for your dates here:More Tour Reviews in St Augustine Florida
- St. Augustine: Waterfront and Downtown Golf Cart Tour
- St. Augustine: Ghosts and Gravestones Old Town Trolley Tour
- St. Augustine: Hop-on Hop-off Trolley Tour with Museum Entry
- St. Augustine: GhoStAugustine Shadow Ride Haunted Tour by EV
- St. Augustine: Dolphin Watching Harbor Tour with Drinks
- Saint Augustine: Bourbon History and Tasting Experience
More St Augustine Florida experiences we've covered
- St. Augustine: Waterfront and Downtown Golf Cart Tour
- St. Augustine: Ghosts and Gravestones Old Town Trolley Tour
- St. Augustine: Hop-on Hop-off Trolley Tour with Museum Entry
- St. Augustine: GhoStAugustine Shadow Ride Haunted Tour by EV
- St. Augustine: Dolphin Watching Harbor Tour with Drinks
- Saint Augustine: Bourbon History and Tasting Experience
- St Augustine: Nights of Lights Sunset Sail with Live Music
- St Augustine: Nights of Lights Tour by Electric Cart
- St. Augustine: Devil’s Hour Paranormal Investigation Tour
- St Augustine: Sunset History Golf Cart Tour
- St. Augustine: The Black Raven Rum Runners Pirate Show (21+)
- St.Augustine History Tour on Premium Golf Cart with PiCk Up
