Exploring Door County from the Water: A 23′ Pontoon Rental Review
When it comes to appreciating the natural beauty of Door County, there’s no better vantage point than from the water. For a reasonable price of $275 per group, you can rent a 2022 Harris 23-foot Cruiser pontoon with a 115-horsepower engine—a boat that promises both comfort and power. Starting at Sister Bay, this experience lasts approximately 3 hours and 30 minutes, making it a perfect half-day adventure. Whether you’re planning a laid-back family outing, a fun day with friends, or even a pup-friendly cruise, this rental offers a flexible and accessible way to explore the scenic shoreline and hidden coves.
What we love most about this experience is the top-tier boat quality and the powerful engine that easily outshines competitors, ensuring plenty of speed and fun. Plus, the wrap-around seating with ample space for coolers and gear makes for a comfortable day on the water. However, it’s worth noting that extra charges for watersports equipment like tubes or skis can add up, and some reviews mention inconsistency in customer service. Still, if you’re after stunning vistas and a smooth rental process, this outing might be just right. It’s best suited for those who value reliable equipment and knowledgeable guides, and who want a flexible, family-friendly adventure with options to add watersports.
Key Points
- Power and Comfort: The boat’s 115-horsepower engine and spacious wrap-around seating make for a lively yet relaxing experience.
- Flexible Options: You can add fun extras like tubes, wakeboards, or a lily pad for a customizable day on the water.
- Customer Experience: Most reviewers praise the friendly staff and smooth rental process, though some note inconsistent service.
- Ideal for All: Perfect for families, groups, or pet owners seeking a scenic, hassle-free way to see Door County.
- Pricing and Value: At $275 for up to 12 people, it offers good value, especially for half-day adventures.
- Booking Tips: Book at least 18 days in advance for the best availability; cancellations are free if made 24 hours ahead.
A Detailed Look at the Pontoon Experience
Planning more time in Green Bay and Door County? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
The Boat: Comfort Meets Power
The 2022 Harris Cruiser pontoon is not your average rental boat. With a 115-horsepower Mercury outboard, it delivers enough muscle to handle wakeboarding or tubing, especially when you add the watersports package for an extra $34. The boat’s size—23 feet long—provides comfortable wrap-around seating for up to 12 guests, which is ideal for families or groups of friends wanting to spread out without feeling cramped.
The boat’s features include a retractable Bimini top for sun protection, an extended swim platform for easy access to the water, and a fold-up swim ladder that makes getting in and out of the water simple. It’s also equipped with a stereo with Bluetooth connectivity, so you can listen to your favorite tunes while cruising the shoreline, adding a personal touch to your trip.
Safety and Convenience
Safety is a priority, with life vests, flares, and dock lines included. The depth finder helps you avoid shallow areas, which some reviews indicate can be a concern if you’re unfamiliar with the water. The boat’s fenders help prevent damage when docking, and all necessary safety gear is provided, so you can focus on having fun.
The Departure and Return
Your adventure begins at Northern Door County Boat Rental in Sister Bay, a location praised for its convenience and easy access. The rental process is straightforward; most reviews highlight how the staff take care of launching the boat, often taking it out of the harbor for you so you can hop on directly from the dock. The start time at 9:30 am is perfect for a full morning or afternoon of exploring.
What to Expect on the Water
On the water, your options are flexible. Many reviewers mention how knowledgeable the staff are about the local spots, guiding you to scenic beaches, quiet coves, or points of interest. Some reviewers rave about their “perfect afternoon,” emphasizing how the boat was spotless and easy to operate. Others enjoy the practicality of the dock assistance, which makes launching and returning hassle-free, especially for less experienced boaters.
Additional Fun: Watersports and Extras
While the base rental includes the boat and safety gear, adding a watersports package (like tubes, wakeboards, or skis) can elevate your day, though it does come at an extra cost. Many reviews highlight how much fun they had tubing or wakeboarding behind the boat, with some calling it “the best part of their trip to Door County.”
The Reviews: Authentic Perspectives
Most feedback is positive, with enthusiastic praise for the staff and boat quality. One reviewer mentions, “What a great company to rent from. They took the boat out of the harbor for us, so we could just hop on from the dock and not worry about the other boats in the marina.” This suggests a level of service that prioritizes convenience and ease.
On the flip side, some reviews point out inconsistencies—poor customer service and additional charges—highlighting the importance of clear communication and understanding of extra costs beforehand. For example, a customer noted, “Lots of extra charges. Unresponsive when needing help,” but also explained that damages to the propeller were caused by shallow water, which emphasizes the need for awareness while navigating.
Practical Tips for Your Rental
- Book early: Most bookings are made about 18 days in advance, so plan ahead.
- Bring your cooler: The boat has enough space for coolers and gear, and reviewers suggest asking for the ice cooler with ice.
- Add watersports: If you’re looking for more active fun, consider the extra package, but be aware of potential additional charges.
- Understand the cancellation policy: Free cancellations are available if you cancel at least 24 hours before, which offers flexibility if weather turns bad.
Who Should Consider This Experience?
This pontoon rental is ideal for families seeking a relaxed, scenic day, groups of friends wanting to enjoy water-based fun, or pet owners looking to include their pups in the adventure. It’s especially appealing to those who value powerful engines for speedy cruising and spacious seating for comfort and socializing.
If you’re after a more luxurious or guided experience, this may not be the best fit, but for independent explorers who want control over their day on Door County’s waterways, it offers excellent value and flexibility. Just keep in mind some reviews mention variable customer service, so staying clear on policies and charges in advance will help ensure a smooth outing.
The Sum Up
A 23’ pontoon rental in Door County with Northern Door County Boat Rental delivers a dependable, enjoyable, and affordable way to explore the area from the water. The boat’s powerful engine and spacious design make it suitable for groups wanting to cruise comfortably and have fun tubing or swimming. The friendly staff and flexible booking process are significant pluses, especially if you plan ahead.
While there are some occasional inconsistent reviews about customer service and extra charges, these don’t overshadow the overall value—especially considering how much you get for the price. It’s a fantastic choice for families, groups, pet owners, or those eager to see Door County from a different perspective.
If your goal is a laid-back, fun-filled day on the water with plenty of room for everyone and options to add watersports, this rental could be just what you’re looking for. It’s about making lasting memories, enjoying the scenery, and having the freedom to chart your own course along Door County’s beautiful shoreline.
FAQs
How long is the rental?
The rental lasts approximately 3 hours and 30 minutes, giving you plenty of time to explore, swim, or just relax on the water.
What is included in the price?
The price of $275 includes the boat itself along with all necessary safety equipment such as life vests, flares, and dock lines.
Can I bring my own food and drinks?
Yes, there’s plenty of space for coolers and gear, and most reviewers appreciate bringing their own food and drinks for a picnic on the water.
Are watersports available?
Watersports like tubing, wakeboarding, or waterskis are not included in the base price but can be added for an extra $34.
Is the boat suitable for pets?
Yes, reviews note that pet owners are welcome, and the boat’s spacious layout is pet-friendly.
What should I know about booking and cancellations?
Bookings should be made at least 18 days in advance for availability. Cancellations are free up to 24 hours before the rental start time.
Is there a minimum age or experience needed?
Most travelers of most ages can participate; the boat is straightforward to operate with guidance, but always check with the staff if you’re unsure.
What if the weather turns bad?
The experience is dependent on good weather. If canceled due to poor conditions, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund.
This pontoon rental offers a balanced mix of fun, comfort, and scenic beauty—perfect for those eager to enjoy the best of Door County from the water. Whether you’re after relaxing cruising, family adventures, or active watersports, it provides the foundation for a memorable day on Wisconsin’s lakes and shoreline.