A Fresh Take on Exploring New Buffalo:
The New Buffalo Bash Scavenger Hunt offers a lively, interactive way to see this charming Michigan town. Priced at $27 per person, this 2-hour adventure begins at Starbucks on N Whittaker St, where you’ll meet your friendly, live host who guides you through a series of clues and challenges. Unlike typical tours, this experience combines creative problem-solving, social interaction, and hidden gems, all wrapped into a mobile, flexible format.
What we particularly like is the personalized guidance from your remote host, which keeps the game engaging and social, even if you’re exploring solo or with a small group. The second is the balance of indoor and outdoor elements, making it suitable regardless of the weather or your preferred pace. A potential drawback could be that the experience relies heavily on your phone and internet connection, so travelers wanting a more traditional, bus-based tour might find this format a bit unconventional.
This activity is a great fit for families, couples, small groups, and adventurous locals looking for a fun way to explore New Buffalo from a different perspective. If you like discovering local secrets, enjoy solving puzzles, or want a flexible, socially interactive experience, this scavenger hunt is worth considering.
- Interactive and Live Guidance: Your remote host makes the experience more personal and engaging.
- Flexible Format: Walk, drive, and explore at your own pace within the two-hour window.
- Family and Dog Friendly: Suitable for all ages and pets, with indoor and outdoor challenges.
- Discover Hidden Gems: Uncover lesser-known spots and local secrets off the usual tourist trail.
- Creative Challenges: Clues involve art, history, and culture, making the experience educational as well as fun.
- Great for Group Activities: Ideal for birthdays, team-building, or curious travelers looking for something different.
Exploring the New Buffalo Bash Scavenger Hunt in Detail

What Makes This Experience Unique?
Unlike guided bus or walking tours where a guide lectures or narrates, this adventure puts you in the driver’s seat — well, the game’s driver, anyway. The live remote host adds an element of fun and encouragement, guiding you with clues and challenges sent via your phone. The company behind this, Alley Kat Adventures, specializes in custom event design for over 300 cities, which means the experience is crafted to be engaging, playful, and tailored to the city’s character.
This local flavor combined with the interactive format offers a kind of adventure that’s more than just sightseeing — it’s detective work, art interpretation, and cultural discovery rolled into one. You’ll be racing against an international leaderboard, which adds a competitive edge, but the real goal is the memorable moments and laughs along the way.
Planning more time in Michigan? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
Starting Point and Logistics
The adventure kicks off at a Starbucks in downtown New Buffalo, a convenient meeting point close to public transportation and easy to find. The activity concludes right back at the start, making it a neat, self-contained outing. The cost of $27 per person is quite reasonable for the two-hour experience, especially considering the personalized guidance and the fun of exploring on your own terms.
What to Expect During the Hunt
Once you receive your digital quest, you’ll be set loose into the town to visit a variety of curated locations. The clues often involve local art, historical sites, or quirky landmarks, encouraging you to interpret your findings and interact with locals. Many reviews mention the wacky challenges and the chance to photo document your progress, which makes the game interactive and lively.
Throughout the hunt, your host will cheer you on via text, help you with tricky clues, and keep the energy high. The experience is designed to be family-friendly and dog-friendly, so everyone from small children to four-legged friends can join in. The mix of indoor and outdoor segments keeps things dynamic, and bonus challenges keep the game fresh and engaging.
Authenticity and Local Secrets
The real charm here is in discovering hidden gems and local secrets that travelers often overlook. The clues are crafted to lead you to spots that might not be on a typical tourist map, offering an authentic slice of New Buffalo life. According to reviews, the guides are knowledgeable and enthusiastic, helping to make the experience more personal.
Potential Drawbacks
Given that the event depends on your phone and internet connection, technical hiccups could occur, especially in areas with poor service. Also, since it is a small-group experience (max 15), larger groups might need to split up or schedule separately. Lastly, the activity’s two-hour length is perfect for a light adventure, but those seeking a more in-depth tour might find it too brief.
- Grand Haven Afternoon Guided Bike & Beer Tour – 3 Hours
- Dragon Rolls Sushi Making Class in Grand Rapids
- Self-Guided Scavenger Hunt: Lansing, At The Heart Of Michigan
- Adventurous Scavenger Hunt in Lansing by Wacky Walks
- 2 hour ATV, UTV, or Dune Buggy Rental for Silver Lake Sand Dunes
- Arrival Private Transfer: Detroit Airport DTW to Detroit in Business Car
Who Should Consider This Tour?
This scavenger hunt is ideal for families, friends, corporate groups, or solo explorers who enjoy interactive, self-guided activities. It’s especially suited for those wanting to combine sightseeing with a creative challenge and a bit of friendly competition. If you’re curious about local art, history, or simply looking for an unconventional way to explore, this experience delivers.
The New Buffalo Bash Scavenger Hunt offers a fresh, engaging twist on town exploration. For $27, you’re getting a personalized, interactive adventure designed to be fun, social, and slightly unpredictable. The guidance of a live host enhances the experience, providing a sense of connection and encouragement that’s often missing from purely digital or self-guided tours.
The balance of indoor and outdoor challenges makes it flexible and suitable regardless of weather, while the focus on hidden gems and local secrets means you’re likely to leave with a richer understanding of New Buffalo than if you simply wandered around on your own. The activity’s emphasis on creative problem-solving and photo documentation caters to modern travelers who enjoy sharing their experiences.
While it may not suit travelers looking for a traditional, narrated tour or those without reliable phone service, this scavenger hunt shines as a fun, social, and memorable way to explore a small town with big character. It’s a brilliant choice for those wanting a mix of light exercise, cultural discovery, and just enough competition to keep things lively.
FAQs

Is this activity suitable for children?
Yes, it’s family-friendly and suitable for children, especially since it involves fun challenges and interactive clues accessible to all ages.
Can I do this activity with my dog?
Absolutely. The tour is dog-friendly, so bringing your furry companion along is encouraged.
How long does the activity last?
Approximately two hours, making it a perfect short outing or a fun addition to a day’s itinerary.
What should I bring?
Bring a charged phone, comfortable walking shoes, and perhaps a camera or smartphone for photos. It’s also wise to dress for the weather.
Is there a maximum group size?
Yes, the group is limited to 15 travelers, which helps keep the experience intimate and personalized.
Can I cancel if I change my mind?
Yes, you can cancel for free up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. Cancellations within 24 hours are non-refundable.
To sum it up, the New Buffalo Bash Scavenger Hunt is a smart pick for travelers who want to explore Michigan’s lakeside charm in a lively, interactive way. It’s especially suited for those who enjoy puzzles, local secrets, and a bit of friendly competition. If you’re after a memorable, playful experience that blends discovery with social fun, this adventure is well worth your time.
More Tour Reviews in Michigan
More Michigan experiences we've covered
- Best of Boyne – Full Day Private Experience
- The NON BUS Torch Lake Traverse City Area Wine Tour
- Sushi Making Cooking Class With Local Chef in Grand Rapids
- Fat Thursday Celebrating an Annual Polish Tradition
- Capturing Charlevoix – Full Day Private Experience
- Port Austin Prowl Scavenger Hunt
- Private 20 Minute River Ride Tour
- Learn to Forge, experiential learning, hands-on forge experience
- Lively Lansing Scavenger Hunt
- Private Custom Tour with a Local Guide Salt Lake City
- Port Huron Prowl Scavenger Hunt
- Frankenmuth Fiasco Scavenger Hunt
