A Taste of Staten Island: The St. George Pizza Tour
If you’re looking for a way to combine great food with a touch of local history, the Staten Island St. George Pizza Tour offers a memorable two-hour journey around one of New York City’s often-overlooked boroughs. For just $20 per person, you’ll explore four different pizza parlors in the charming neighborhood of Saint George, all while learning about Staten Island’s unique character from a knowledgeable guide, Nancy. The tour lasts approximately 2 hours and 7 minutes, making it a perfect afternoon escape from the hustle of Manhattan.
What we really loved about this experience are two specific aspects: first, the way the guide brings Staten Island’s story to life, giving context to each stop beyond just the pizza. Second, the variety of pizza flavors and styles at different local spots showcases the island’s culinary creativity. A possible consideration is that, with only an hour and a half dedicated to pizza tastings, it’s a rather quick tour — but that means you can easily add other sightseeing or shopping at nearby attractions.
This tour is ideal for food lovers who want a taste of local life without breaking the bank, and for travelers curious about Staten Island’s lesser-known corners. It’s particularly suitable if you enjoy storytelling and scenic strolls, making it a well-rounded outing for those interested in both culture and cuisine.
Key Points
- Affordable and well-paced at $20, offering good value for a mix of food and local history.
- Narrative-driven experience with a guide who shares stories about Staten Island’s landmarks and culture.
- Diverse pizza stops showcase different styles and flavors, appealing to a broad range of tastes.
- Convenient location starting at the Staten Island Ferry terminal, with spectacular views of the Manhattan skyline and Statue of Liberty.
- Short and sweet—around 2 hours—making it easy to slot into a day of sightseeing.
- Authentic local experience beyond touristy spots, giving a genuine taste of Staten Island’s community.
Exploring Staten Island’s Hidden Culinary Gems: The Full Breakdown
Planning more time in Staten Island? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
Starting at the Ferry: Scenic Water Views and a Classic Commute
The tour begins at the Staten Island Ferry Terminal, a spot that offers incredible views of the city skyline and the Statue of Liberty. We love how this setup makes the journey feel more than just a food tour—it’s a scenic voyage from Manhattan that sets the mood. As you hop on the ferry, you’ll see the skyline’s shimmering reflections and the iconic Lady Liberty, all part of the first impression of Staten Island’s quiet charm.
The ferry ride itself isn’t just transportation; it’s part of the experience, offering about 25 minutes of stunning water views. You’ll pass by the waterfront shopping hub, Empire Outlets, which is right after disembarking. If you arrive early, it’s a lively spot for a quick browse or coffee before the tour begins.
Meet Your Guide and Begin the Culinary Journey in St. George
Your guide, Nancy, welcomes you to the neighborhood, and from there, the tour kicks off. The heart of the experience is the four pizza parlors, each offering a different slice of Staten Island’s pizza scene. What makes this tour stand out is how Nancy not only takes you to tasty spots but also shares insights into Staten Island’s history and local trends.
The first stop is a beloved pizza joint where you might find a classic New York-style slice, featuring a perfectly crispy crust, gooey cheese, and rich tomato sauce. Moving on, the subsequent parlors introduce you to different styles—perhaps a more artisanal or innovative take—highlighting the island’s culinary diversity. The focus is on quality and authenticity, not just quick bites.
Highlights of Key Stops and Landmarks
While the main focus is pizza, the tour thoughtfully includes visits to notable landmarks like the St. George Theatre, an architectural gem with a grand facade and fine acoustics. Another stop is the National Lighthouse Museum, housed in a historic building that once served as a lighthouse depot—an excellent way to add cultural and historical context to your culinary adventure.
The Staten Island Borough Hall also features in the tour, offering a glimpse into the island’s civic heart. These landmarks not only enrich your understanding of Staten Island but also break up the tasting portions with some beautiful scenery and storytelling.
Authentic Local Experience and Personal Touches
What we found particularly touching is the genuine warmth of the guide, Nancy, who shares stories and details that you won’t find in guidebooks. For example, as one reviewer noted, “Nancy did an amazing job in giving us the background to Staten Island,” which really made the experience feel personal and engaging.
The tour size is small—up to 20 travelers—ensuring plenty of interaction and personalized attention. This smaller group makes it easier to ask questions and truly enjoy the shared experience.
Timing, Transportation, and Overall Value
The tour starts at 1:00 pm, making it ideal for combining with other sightseeing. Since it’s located near public transportation and begins at a central spot, it’s accessible for most travelers staying in or near Manhattan.
At just $20, it offers excellent value considering the variety of pizza, the cultural insights, and the scenic views included. It’s a budget-friendly way to enjoy a different side of NYC, especially if you’re a pizza fan or curious about Staten Island.
What we loved—and what to consider
The storytelling and local flavor are the tour’s biggest strengths. The fact that you get to sample four different pizzas means you’ll leave full and satisfied, with plenty of new favorites to try later. The scenic boat ride, combined with visits to landmarks, makes this more than just a food crawl — it’s a mini sightseeing tour with a delicious twist.
One minor consideration is the quick pace; if you’re someone who prefers to linger and savor each bite, this might feel a bit rushed. But for most, the balance of tasting and learning hits the right note.
Who will love this tour?
This experience suits travelers who appreciate authentic local flavor and enjoy short, engaging outings. It’s perfect for those who want to combine scenic views, history, and food without committing an entire day. If you’re traveling with friends or family and want a relaxed, fun way to explore Staten Island’s culinary scene, this tour hits the mark. It’s also a good pick for first-timers in the area wanting to get a quick, meaningful snapshot of the borough’s character.
FAQs
Is the tour suitable for all ages?
Yes, most travelers can participate, and the pacing is suitable for a broad age range. Just keep in mind the tour involves walking and eating, so comfortable shoes are recommended.
How long does the tour last?
It runs approximately 2 hours and 7 minutes, including visits to four pizza parlors and landmark stops.
Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, the tour is popular, booked on average 17 days in advance, so planning ahead is advised.
What if the weather is bad?
The tour requires good weather, and if canceled due to rain or storms, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund.
Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, cancellations are free up to 24 hours in advance, allowing flexibility for your schedule.
Is transportation included?
Transportation to the start point is not included, but the ferry ride itself is part of the experience, with the starting point accessible by public transit.
In the end, the Staten Island St. George Pizza Tour is a delightful way to taste the island’s best slices while soaking in local sights and stories. It’s perfect for curious travelers eager to experience Staten Island beyond the usual tourist spots, and for those who appreciate good food with a side of history. With friendly guides, scenic views, and authentic pizza stops, it offers a genuinely enjoyable slice of New York life — both literally and figuratively.