Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour

Discover Mystic’s Haunted Side with a Craft Beer Twist

If you’re headed to Mystic, Connecticut, and enjoy a good story as much as a good brew, the Paranormal Pub Crawl: Beer Tour offers a spirited evening of both. Priced at $75 per person, this 2.5-hour adventure takes you through downtown Mystic’s most historic pubs and breweries, stopping at three key spots. Led by engaging guides, you’ll sample Barley Head beers while uncovering tales of hauntings, massacres, and scandals that have left their mark on the town’s dark corners.

What we find particularly appealing about this tour is the combination of craft beer tasting with local ghost stories. The relaxed pace means you can really enjoy each stop without feeling rushed, and the stories add a layer of intrigue you won’t get on a regular pub crawl. Plus, with three complimentary beers included, you’re getting value for your money.

One potential consideration is that the tour runs rain or shine—so be prepared for the weather, especially if you’re visiting outside of the warmer months. If you’re someone who appreciates a lively, storytelling atmosphere paired with historic sites, this tour is likely to be a hit.

This experience works best for those who enjoy history, ghost stories, and craft beer—perfect for couples, friends, or anyone curious about Mystic’s haunted past with a fun twist.

Key Points

Authentic Haunted Experience: Walk through downtown Mystic hearing true ghost stories and local legends.
Craft Beer Sampling: Enjoy three free beers from Barley Head Brewing at different historic pubs.
Engaging Guides: Guides like Sierra make the stories lively and memorable.
Historical Insights: Discover the darker side of Mystic’s history, including massacres, hauntings, and scandals.
Weather-Resilient: Operates rain or shine, so dress appropriately for the weather.
Small Group Feel: Max of 35 travelers ensures a personal experience.

For evening entertainment in Mystic, here are other options we've explored

A Detailed Look at the Paranormal Pub Crawl Experience

Starting Point and Atmosphere

We begin on West Main Street & Water Street in downtown Mystic at 7:30 pm. The meeting spot is easy to find, and the group feels intimate, setting a cozy tone for the evening. The tour’s mobile ticket system makes check-in seamless, and most travelers find the timing perfect for a post-dinner activity.

The atmosphere is casual—perfect for those who enjoy storytelling in a lively setting. The guide, Sierra, receives high praise for her friendly demeanor and depth of knowledge. Her storytelling style makes the ghost tales engaging without feeling overly theatrical.

Stop 1: Historic Downtown Mystic and the Old Book Store Hauntings

The tour kicks off by exploring Historic Downtown Mystic and the stories tied to a former book store haunted by the Mystic Massacre. While brief—about 15 minutes—it sets a tone of intrigue and introduces the mix of history and ghostly legend that will permeate the evening. The site’s connection to local tragedies makes it a compelling starting point.

Stop 2: The Harp and Hound

Next, you’ll visit The Harp and Hound, where the stories of Mystic hauntings and the Massacre continue. Spending about 25 minutes here, you’ll get a chance to sample a Barley Head brew and hear about the local spirits said to linger. The guide’s storytelling, combined with the pub’s cozy ambiance, makes this stop memorable.

While you're exploring Mystic, here are other experiences we've looked into

Stop 3: 15 Water Street and Its Scandals

The third stop is 15 Water Street, a historic location with tales of local scandals and hauntings. A quick 15-minute visit, but packed with stories that deepen your understanding of Mystic’s often turbulent past. The charm of hearing ghost stories in such an atmospheric setting makes this stop a favorite for many.

Stop 4: Captain Daniel Packer Inne and Revolutionary Ghosts

A highlight is the Captain Daniel Packer Inne, where the ghostly tales revolve around Revolutionary War spirits and the playful Giggling Ghost. Over about 25 minutes, you’ll enjoy your second beer while learning about spirits that allegedly have a sense of humor. The historic inn’s cozy tavern feel amplifies the ghostly tales.

Stop 5: Friar Tuck’s Tavern and the Grand Finale

Finally, at Friar Tuck’s Tavern, the tour wraps up with stories of local folklore and mysteries. Here, you’ll enjoy your third beer, with about 30 minutes to relax and reflect on the stories. The lively atmosphere leaves many with a sense of having touched Mystic’s darker past.

Authentic Experiences and Practical Details

The Guides Make It Special

Feedback highlights guides like Sierra for being friendly, informative, and capable of making stories come alive. Such guides turn what could be an ordinary pub crawl into an engaging history lesson sprinkled with ghostly tales. Their storytelling makes the history feel real and personal, adding a layer of authenticity.

The Value of Included Beers

With three complimentary beers, you’ll get a good taste of Barley Head’s offerings, making the cost of $75 feel reasonable. The beers are served at each pub, allowing plenty of time to savor the flavors and chat with fellow travelers or the guide about the stories.

The Itinerary and Timing

The schedule is well-balanced, with stops lasting between 15 and 30 minutes, giving ample time to enjoy your drink and listen to stories without feeling rushed. The entire tour clocks in at around 2 hours 30 minutes, ideal for an early evening activity.

Weather Considerations

Since the tour is rain or shine, packing an umbrella or raincoat is wise, especially if visiting during cooler or wetter months. The outdoor stops mean you’ll want to be prepared for the weather but rest assured that the experience continues regardless of conditions.

Who Should Consider This Tour?

This tour is perfect for history buffs, ghost story lovers, or anyone who appreciates local lore and craft beer. It’s especially suitable for those who enjoy a relaxed, storytelling-driven experience rather than a boisterous bar crawl. Couples, friends, or solo travelers looking to combine mystery, history, and a taste of local brewing will find plenty to love here.

The Sum Up: Is It Worth Your Time?

The Paranormal Pub Crawl offers a unique blend of Mystic’s haunted past and local craft beers, wrapped in an approachable, engaging format. The guides’ storytelling elevates the experience from a simple pub visit to a memorable journey through the town’s darker stories. For just $75, you get three beers, intriguing tales, and a chance to see Mystic from a different perspective.

If you’re looking for a fun, authentic way to explore Mystic’s history—minus the tourist traps—this tour delivers. It’s especially well-suited for those who enjoy local legends and historic settings combined with a laid-back social atmosphere. Just remember to dress for the weather, and you’ll have a night full of stories and spirits to remember.

FAQ

How long is the Paranormal Pub Crawl?
It lasts approximately 2 hours 30 minutes, making it a perfect early evening activity.

What’s included in the price?
You receive three free beers during the tour, served at different pubs and locations.

Is the tour suitable for all weather?
Yes, it operates rain or shine, so dress accordingly for outdoor stops.

What’s the group size?
The tour accommodates up to 35 travelers, ensuring a lively but manageable group.

Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at West Main Street & Water Street in Mystic and ends at the Captain Daniel Packer Inne on Water Street.

Can I join if I don’t drink alcohol?
While the tour includes beer, you might still enjoy the stories and atmosphere if you prefer non-alcoholic options—just check with the provider in advance.

Is the tour family-friendly?
The focus on ghost stories and historic tales makes it suitable for older children and adults. Younger children might find it less engaging.

Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, on average, travelers book about 39 days ahead, especially in peak seasons.

Are refunds available?
No, all sales are final. The tour will only be canceled for weather or insufficient bookings, with options for rescheduling or full refund.

Who should I contact for questions about the tour?
You can reach out via web chat or email at [email protected] or call +1 860-754-8923 for inquiries.

This Mystic paranormal pub crawl combines history, storytelling, and local craft beers into a memorable evening. Whether you’re a history buff, a ghost story enthusiast, or just looking for a fun night out, it’s a lively way to experience the town’s darker stories with a friendly guide.