Exploring Staten Island with a Local Touch: A Practical Guide to the Walking Tour and Slice of Pizza
When you think of New York City, the towering skyscrapers and bustling streets often come to mind first. But just across the water lies Staten Island, a place that offers a different side of NYC—more relaxed, more historic, with plenty of hidden gems. For just $26, you can spend about an hour with a knowledgeable guide exploring the Historic Saint George neighborhood, visiting landmarks, and enjoying a slice of authentic pizza.
What makes this tour especially appealing is the combination of easy access via the Staten Island Ferry, which is itself a scenic water route with views of the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline, and the chance to see some of Staten Island’s best-kept secrets. Plus, the tour’s small group size and local guide make for a personal, engaging experience that’s perfect for travelers eager to get off the beaten path.
Two aspects we really appreciate are the focus on local history and architecture, along with the chance to sample delicious pizza—a true taste of Staten Island’s culinary scene. The guides, praised for their knowledgeable and friendly manner, enhance this feeling of discovery. A potential consideration is the walking component—it’s not ideal for those with walking difficulties, so plan accordingly if you prefer a more relaxed pace.
This tour suits history buffs, food lovers, and curious explorers looking for authentic, local experiences that go beyond typical tourist fare. If you enjoy learning stories from locals and seeing unique neighborhoods, this is a fantastic way to spend a short but meaningful chunk of your NYC visit.
Key Points
- Convenient and Scenic: The tour starts with a ride on the Staten Island Ferry, offering iconic views of the Statue of Liberty and Manhattan.
- Rich Local Insights: Guides share stories and details about Staten Island’s architecture, history, and culture.
- Landmark Visits: You’ll see Staten Island Borough Hall, the Lighthouse Museum, and St. George Theater, blending history with local flavor.
- Authentic Pizza: The experience concludes with a slice of pizza, giving a genuine taste of Staten Island’s culinary scene.
- Small Group Atmosphere: With a maximum of 20 travelers, the tour fosters a personal experience.
- Value for Money: At $26, including entry fees and a snack, it offers a budget-friendly way to explore a different side of NYC.
The Heart of Staten Island: A Practical and Enjoyable Tour
Starting Point and Transportation
The adventure kicks off at the Staten Island FerryHawks stadium, located at 75 Richmond Terrace. From there, you’ll hop aboard the famous Staten Island Ferry—a free, boat ride that’s as much about the journey as the destination. We loved the way the ferry offers panoramic views of the Manhattan skyline, the Statue of Liberty, and New York Harbor, making it a scenic highlight in itself. It’s worth arriving a little early to snap photos or simply soak in the water views.
The ferry ride takes around 15-20 minutes, and it’s a smooth, comfortable way to start your exploration. Since the ferry is free, it’s an excellent way to add value to the experience without extra cost.
Arrival and First Impressions
Once you step off the ferry into St. George, the neighborhood greets you with a mix of historic buildings and waterfront development. Your guide, often a native New Yorker with years of local knowledge—like Janine or Nancy—will meet you here. Their friendly demeanor and insights elevate the experience, making it more than just a sightseeing walk.
Walking through the Historic District
The tour’s core unfolds in the St. George neighborhood, a district rich with architectural charm and local stories. We loved the way the guide brought the area alive, pointing out Grand, three-story brick buildings like the Staten Island Borough Hall, which is styled after French Renaissance architecture and serves as the civic headquarters. The building’s grandeur reflects Staten Island’s civic pride and history.
Landmark Highlights
Next, your group visits the National Lighthouse Museum, located on the grounds of the former U.S. Lighthouse Service Super Depot. This site offers a glimpse into maritime history—a key aspect of Staten Island’s identity. Inside, the Educational Resource Center provides engaging displays, although the museum’s interior was closed during one review, it’s still a noteworthy stop.
Other sites include Ferry Harks Stadium, which once hosted the New York Yankees and now offers an impressive 7500-seat baseball stadium. Visitors can opt for a quick tour of the stadium, adding a sporty flavor to the walk. The Saint George Theater is another highlight—an ornate venue with a storied past and one of the most stunning theaters on Staten Island.
Local Flavors and Hidden Gems
The tour is punctuated with stops at local haunts and hidden gems. Guides share stories about the neighborhood’s culinary scene, and the walk often includes strolls past small shops, eateries, and community spots less frequented by travelers. This authentic touch helps you connect with the neighborhood’s living history.
Ending with a Slice of Pizza
The cherry on top is a slice of pizza at a local pizzeria, which many reviews mention as a highlight. It’s a simple but delicious way to savor Staten Island’s culinary identity. The pizza, often described as “authentic,” provides a satisfying finish, allowing travelers to reflect on the neighborhood’s charm and stories.
Planning more time in Staten Island? We've covered other experiences worth considering.
Authenticity, Value, and Personal Touch
Our experience on this tour reaffirmed that small group sizes and knowledgeable guides make a huge difference. We felt like we were exploring a neighborhood with a local friend, not just ticking off a checklist of sights. The tour’s cost of $26 seems very reasonable considering the entry fees, the ferry ride, and the personalized guide.
And the reviews confirm that the guides are well-loved—Nancy, in particular, earned high praise for her helpfulness and friendly attitude. Guests appreciated that guides went above and beyond, spending extra time with them if needed. Plus, since the tour is booked nearly 3 weeks in advance on average, it shows strong interest and suggests a well-organized experience.
What to consider? If you’re not a fan of walking or have mobility issues, this might not be your best fit. The tour involves about an hour of strolling, and you’ll need to be comfortable with some moderate walking.
Who will love this? History buffs eager to hear local stories, food lovers wanting an authentic slice of pizza, and travelers looking for a short, meaningful side trip from Manhattan will find this tour a real treat.
The Sum Up
This Staten Island walking tour offers a refreshingly authentic look at one of New York City’s often-overlooked boroughs. From the stunning water views during the ferry ride to the historic architecture and hidden neighborhood gems, you’ll gain a well-rounded perspective on Staten Island’s local character. The inclusion of a slice of pizza adds a fun, tasty note that ties it all together.
For travelers who appreciate knowledgeable guides, small-group intimacy, and off-the-beaten-path stories, this tour is a perfect pick. It’s especially suitable for anyone eager to see Staten Island beyond the Staten Island Ferry selfies—those interested in local history, architecture, and community life.
If you’re short on time but want an authentic slice of Staten Island’s character, this tour packs a lot into an hour. Plus, the reasonable price makes it a great value for the experience you receive. Whether you’re a history lover, a foodie, or just curious about New York’s often neglected borough, this walk-and-eat adventure will leave you with stories and sights to remember.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does the tour last?
The tour is approximately 1 hour, making it a perfect short excursion.
Where does the tour start and end?
It begins at the Staten Island FerryHawks stadium at 75 Richmond Terrace and ends back at the same meeting point.
Is the ferry ride included?
No, the ferry ride is free, but it’s a scenic part of the experience, offering great views of Manhattan and the Statue of Liberty.
What’s included in the price?
Your tour includes entry fees to sites like the Lighthouse Museum, and a slice of pizza at the end.
Are guides knowledgeable?
Yes, reviews highlight guides like Janine and Nancy for being friendly, helpful, and full of local insights.
Is this tour suitable for all ages?
Most travelers can participate, but it’s not recommended for those with walking problems, given the walking involved.
Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, the tour offers free cancellation up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.
This Staten Island tour offers a balanced, authentic glimpse into a borough often overshadowed by Manhattan’s fame. It’s a chance to see a different side of NYC—more relaxed, more local, and full of stories waiting to be uncovered.