Imagine stepping into a 1920s speakeasy, complete with jazz music, flapper dresses, and the thrill of crime and intrigue. That’s exactly what you get with this Orlando murder mystery dinner show, set in the intimate Teatro Martini venue. For about two hours, you’ll enjoy a lively, interactive show where you become part of the story, trying to catch a killer amid a backdrop of jazz, bootleggers, and gangsters. The experience includes a delicious three-course meal and plenty of chances to solve clues or simply sit back and enjoy the spectacle.

What makes this experience truly stand out is its interactive nature — you get to vote on the ending and even bribe characters for clues, making every night feel fresh and different. Plus, with a maximum of 165 guests, the atmosphere is cozy enough to feel part of the action but lively enough for plenty of laughs and surprises. It’s a perfect pick for an unusual night out, especially if you enjoy a good story, good food, and a touch of theatrical flair.

Two things we particularly love about this experience are the authenticity of the setting — the venue is decorated to evoke a real 1920s nightclub — and the variety of characters you’ll interact with, from gangsters to flappers, all played with flair and humor. On the flip side, one consideration is that the show is rated PG-13, so it may not be suitable for very young children, and the audience participation, while optional, might feel a bit intimidating for some.

This experience is best suited for adults or older teens who enjoy storytelling, comedy, and a lively atmosphere. If you’re looking for a unique night out that combines entertainment, a meal, and a bit of detective work, this is a great choice.

Key Points

Authentic 1920s Atmosphere: The venue and characters create a genuine speakeasy vibe.
Interactive Experience: Guests participate through voting and clues, making each show unique.
Delicious 3-Course Meal: Food is thoughtfully prepared, adding value to the experience.
Flexible Participation: You can choose how involved you want to be in solving the mystery.
Family-Friendly: Suitable for ages 12 and older, but not ideal for very young children.
Venue Size: Intimate setting with around 165 guests enhances the experience without feeling crowded.

You can check availability for your dates here:

A Detailed Look at the Murder Mystery Experience in Orlando

Planning more time in Florida? We've covered other experiences worth considering.

Setting the Scene: An Authentic 1920s Nightclub

As you arrive at Teatro Martini, you’re greeted by the lively sounds of jazz and the buzz of a bustling 1920s nightclub. The decor transports you back in time, with vintage posters, dim lighting, and the aroma of classic cocktails. The hosts, dressed in period costumes, set the tone for an evening of fun, mystery, and comedy. We loved the way the venue makes you feel like you’re stepping right into a Speakeasy, with its intimate and cozy layout.

The ambiance is crucial here — the music, the costumes, and the set design all contribute to a lively, immersive environment. Whether you’re a history buff or just looking for a novel night out, the setting makes the experience instantly memorable. The venue itself is designed for comfort and interaction, with the audience close enough to the action to feel involved but not overwhelmed.

The Dinner: A Thoughtfully Curated Three-Course Meal

While the focus is on the show, the meal is an important part of the experience. The menu features delicious food and tapas-style options, making it easy to enjoy while interacting with characters or pondering clues. The dinner is served in courses, and guests consistently praise the quality and flavor of the offerings.

One review highlights the “good value for money,” noting that the food surpasses expectations for a show package. The meal complements the evening’s entertainment, giving you enough fuel to stay alert and engaged as you follow the story. The food isn’t just a side note — it’s part of the experience, designed to keep you satisfied without distracting from the mystery.

The Show: An Interactive Crime Dinner

Once everyone is settled, the show kicks off with a lively introduction by the host and characters. The plot revolves around a murder that needs solving, with colorful characters weaving through the audience — from gangsters to flappers, each with their own motives and secrets. The performers are skilled at balancing humor with suspense, creating a light-hearted yet engaging atmosphere.

Throughout the show, characters will drop clues, try to sway your opinion, and engage in humorous banter. The audience has the power to vote on the ending, which means that no two shows are exactly alike. We enjoyed the unpredictability — “You never knew if the clues were legit or just red herrings,” one guest remarked.

More Great Tours Nearby

How Participation Works

Participation is entirely optional — you can sit back and enjoy the spectacle or become a detective. Many guests, like us, appreciated the low-pressure interaction, feeling free to observe or get involved as they pleased. Bribing characters for clues with “bribe money” adds a humorous twist, and it’s fun to see who you can sway.

The ending is decided by audience votes, making each performance a collective adventure. This keeps the experience fresh and encourages repeat visits, as you might want to see how the story unfolds differently next time.

While you're exploring Florida, here are other experiences we've looked into

Authenticity and Audience Engagement

What differentiates this murder mystery is the attention to detail — the costumes, set design, and acting all contribute to a convincing 1920s vibe. The performers are engaging, humorous, and convincing, keeping the energy high. As one reviewer put it, “We felt like part of the scene without feeling pressured to participate.”

The show is rated PG-13, with subject matter that includes some crime and mild language, but nothing overly graphic. It’s suitable for teenagers and adults but not recommended for young children under 8.

Logistics: What You Need to Know

Duration: About 2 hours, including dinner and show.
Location: Teatro Martini, coordinates 28.455629348754883, -81.46814727783203.
Accessibility: The venue is wheelchair accessible, accommodating guests with mobility needs.
Booking: You can reserve in advance with a flexible “reserve now and pay later” option, and free cancellation is available up to 24 hours beforehand.
Group Size: Intimate enough to remain personal but lively enough to keep the energy high.
Price: While not specified exactly, the experience is considered good value considering the meal and entertainment.

What Others Are Saying

Guests often mention how fun and engaging the evening is. One said, “The food was surprisingly good, and the show was hilarious.” Another appreciated how interactive and unpredictable it was, noting that “every show is different, and you really feel like you’re part of the story.” Some mention the atractive vintage decor and comfortable ambiance as highlights.

Potential Drawbacks

A few reviews note that participation is optional but that the atmosphere can sometimes feel a little chaotic or noisy, especially early in the evening. Also, not suitable for very young children, so plan accordingly if traveling with family.

Who Should Consider This Experience?

If you enjoy theater, interactive storytelling, or just a fun night blending comedy and mystery, this show is a fantastic choice. It’s ideal for couples, groups of friends, or solo travelers seeking a different kind of entertainment—especially if you appreciate good food and a lively social scene. It’s also perfect for fans of history or jazz, who can enjoy the period setting.

Those looking for a family night might want to consider the PG-13 rating and age recommendations. If you prefer a more conventional dinner show, this might not be the best fit. However, for a lighthearted, engaging evening, it hits the mark.

Final Thoughts

This Orlando speakeasy murder mystery dinner show offers a unique blend of entertainment, food, and interactive fun. Its authenticity in setting, quality of food, and chance to influence the story make it much more than a typical dinner out. The intimate atmosphere and lively performances leave many guests with memorable stories to tell.

It’s a great pick for those wanting to escape the usual Disney routine and indulge in some theatrical fun with a vintage twist. Whether you’re a seasoned mystery fan or simply in search of a different kind of night out, this experience offers value and entertainment in equal measure.

If you enjoy being part of an unfolding story, love period costumes, or simply want a good laugh over a tasty meal, this show is worth considering for your Orlando trip.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the show suitable for children?
The show is rated PG-13 and is suitable for audiences 12 and older. It’s not recommended for children under 8 years old.

Can I participate in the show?
Participation is completely optional. You can simply watch and enjoy or get involved in clues and voting if you wish.

How long is the experience?
The entire experience lasts around 2 hours, including dinner and the performance.

Where is the venue located?
The show takes place at Teatro Martini, located at coordinates 28.455629348754883, -81.46814727783203.

Is it accessible for wheelchair users?
Yes, the venue is wheelchair accessible, ensuring everyone can enjoy the show comfortably.

Can I cancel my reservation?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, making it flexible for last-minute plans.

What’s included in the price?
Your ticket includes the meal, entertainment, and interactive experience. The food is well-reviewed and considered part of the overall value.

To sum it up, the Orlando Speakeasy Murder Mystery Dinner Show is a lively, immersive experience that combines good food, period-style entertainment, and a chance to test your detective skills. It’s particularly well-suited for adults who enjoy humor, history, and interactive storytelling. With its authentic setting and engaging cast, it promises a memorable night that stands out from typical dinner options. If you’re in Orlando and craving something different to spice up your evening, this show deserves a spot on your list.