Lunch at Iconic Redeye Grill near Central Park and Carnegie Hall!

Planning a visit to New York City and looking for a great spot to enjoy a relaxed, upscale lunch? The Redeye Grill, situated just across from Carnegie Hall and near Broadway, offers a refined yet approachable experience perfect for a midday break. For $41 per person, you’ll get a two-course prix-fixe meal that features some of the best American brasserie classics, served in a lively, elegant setting. The tour lasts about 1 hour and 30 minutes, making it a manageable and satisfying addition to your NYC itinerary.

We love how easily accessible the Redeye Grill is for visitors—located centrally in Midtown Manhattan, it’s ideal whether you’re coming from a show, sightseeing, or just exploring the neighborhood. Two specific aspects stand out: first, the diversity of the menu—from fresh sushi and seafood to juicy steaks and vegetarian bowls—so there’s something to suit almost every taste. Second, the location across from Carnegie Hall means you’re right in the heart of the city’s vibrant arts scene, making it a convenient dining stop before or after a show.

One potential drawback might be the fixed menu—if you have very specific dietary preferences or want a more extensive meal, you might find the choice somewhat limited. Also, at $41, it’s still a mid-range price for NYC, but the quality and location make it a good value, especially for travelers craving an authentic, comfortable dining experience.

This experience is best suited for those looking for a convenient, quality lunch near Broadway or Carnegie Hall. It’s ideal for theater-goers, business travelers on a quick break, or anyone wanting a taste of Manhattan’s classic culinary scene with a relaxed, no-hassle approach.

Key Points

• Prime Location: Situated directly across from Carnegie Hall and near Broadway, perfect for pre- or post-show meals.
• Diverse Menu: Offers sushi, seafood, steaks, and vegetarian options, accommodating various tastes.
• Affordable Luxury: At $41, it provides good value for a high-quality, two-course meal in Midtown NYC.
• Convenient Setting: An elegant, bustling brasserie with a friendly atmosphere, suitable for both casual and special occasions.
• Inclusive Pricing: Gratuities and government fees are included, simplifying the bill.
• Limited Choices: Fixed menu means less flexibility if you’re looking for a broad selection or dietary customization.

A Detailed Look at Your Redeye Grill Lunch Experience

When we first arrive at Redeye Grill, the urban buzz of Midtown surrounds us. The restaurant’s location across from Carnegie Hall is a plus—if you’re catching a concert or just exploring the arts district, it’s hard to beat. We appreciated the easy access—near public transportation and in a lively area that’s always bustling. The interior strikes a balance between refined and approachable, with a classic American brasserie vibe—think warm lighting, polished wood, and a friendly, professional staff.

The lunch menu is straightforward but thoughtfully curated, making decision-making a breeze. For appetizers, options include the Soup of the Day, a Greek Salad with fresh feta and cucumbers, a crisp Caesar Salad, delectable Fried Calamari served with yuzu aioli, or a Shrimp Cocktail—all classic choices executed well. One diner remarked, “The calamari was perfectly crispy, and the yuzu aioli added a nice touch.”

For the main courses, the selection is equally appealing. The Chicken Cobb Salad is hearty, with avocado, blue cheese, bacon, and a perfectly cooked egg. The Black Label Cheeseburger with sharp Tillamook cheddar and crispy fries is a safe bet for comfort food lovers. Seafood fans might enjoy the Grilled Teriyaki Salmon Bowl, featuring fresh fish and seasonal vegetables, or the Blackened Mahi Mahi with citrus beurre blanc. Vegetarians aren’t left out, with options like the Vegetarian Teriyaki Bowl with roasted peppers and mushrooms over brown rice. Several reviews praise the generous portions and fresh ingredients, making each bite satisfying.

The meal includes a soft drink or water, and the gratuity—already included—means no surprises when the check arrives. This transparency is appreciated, especially for travelers trying to manage expenses. The entire experience lasts about 90 minutes, providing a relaxing yet efficient lunch, perfect for fitting into a busy sightseeing schedule.

What Makes This Lunch Stand Out?

Firstly, the menu variety ensures most guests find something they enjoy. Whether you’re craving sushi, a hearty burger, or a seafood bowl, there’s a good chance you’ll leave satisfied. We loved the quality of ingredients—locally sourced fish and fresh produce—making every dish feel thoughtfully prepared.

Secondly, the location cannot be overstated. Being across from Carnegie Hall means you’re in the heart of Midtown, close to theaters, shops, and major attractions. If you’re heading to a show or just exploring the neighborhood, it’s a convenient and comfortable spot to recharge.

Possible Consideration

The fixed menu might feel limiting if you prefer extensive choices or have specific dietary needs. Also, the price of $41 for a two-course lunch is fair for Midtown standards, but not cheap; however, considering the quality, location, and included gratuities, many find it a worthwhile investment.

Who Should Book This Experience?

If you’re after a reliable, high-quality meal in the heart of Manhattan, this lunch ticks all the boxes. It’s especially suited for theater-goers, business travelers, or anyone wanting a taste of NYC’s upscale yet approachable dining scene. It’s ideal for a leisurely break or a quick yet satisfying meal before a show or museum visit.

Final Thoughts

The Redeye Grill lunch offers a balanced blend of quality, convenience, and atmosphere—a perfect stop for travelers wanting a taste of Manhattan’s classic American brasserie style. The location across from Carnegie Hall adds a touch of elegance and makes it a natural choice for those in the arts district.

The fixed menu and mid-range price point might not appeal to those seeking culinary variety or dietary customization, but for most visitors, the value is clear. The inclusive gratuities and straightforward booking make this a hassle-free choice for a memorable NYC midday meal.

In short, if you’re looking to combine authentic New York flavors with an unbeatable location, the Redeye Grill delivers, making your lunch both delicious and convenient.

FAQ

Is the lunch available Monday through Friday?
Yes, the 2-course prix-fixe lunch is offered Monday through Friday from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM.

How far in advance should I book?
Most travelers book about 16 days in advance, but it’s wise to reserve early to secure your preferred date, especially during busy seasons.

Does the price include gratuity and taxes?
Yes, the $41 price includes government fees, taxes, and a 20% gratuity, simplifying the payment process.

Can I order alcohol at this lunch?
Guests must be 21+ years old to order alcoholic beverages, which are available separately and not included in the fixed price menu.

What’s the duration of the lunch experience?
The entire experience lasts approximately 1 hour and 30 minutes, giving you plenty of time to enjoy your meal without feeling rushed.

Are there vegetarian options?
Yes, the menu features vegetarian choices such as the Vegetarian Teriyaki Bowl with mushrooms, spinach, and roasted peppers.

Is this tour suitable for groups of more than 10?
No, the tour is limited to a maximum of 10 travelers, ensuring a more intimate dining experience.

Can I cancel my reservation?
Yes, the booking offers free cancellation up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

Planning a lunch at Redeye Grill means enjoying great food in a prime location with a cozy, elegant atmosphere. It’s a solid choice for anyone wanting a taste of classic New York without straying too far from the city’s entertainment hubs.