A New Take on a Beloved Universe: “Stranger Things: The First Shadow” Broadway Play
When we think of Broadway, we often picture dazzling musicals and iconic performances, but this time, the latest hit brings a dark, suspenseful twist rooted in the Stranger Things universe. Priced at around $97.76 per person, this experience offers nearly three hours of drama, mystery, and nostalgia, set in 1959 Hawkins, Indiana. The adventure begins at the Marquis Theatre, a classic Broadway venue, and continues with a visit to the vibrant heart of Broadway itself.
What we love most about this production is its ability to weave famous characters and mythology into a compelling stand-alone story that feels both fresh and familiar. The play’s setting within the Stranger Things universe allows fans to explore the town’s dark secrets through a new lens—think of it as a prequel with a heavy dose of suspense. Plus, the stunning theatrical effects and set design truly make you wonder, “How did they do that?”—a perfect treat for anyone who appreciates spectacle.
A potential drawback is that the play is quite intense, especially with content that may be unsettling for younger audiences or those sensitive to darker themes. It’s recommended for ages 12+, with younger children under 5 not permitted inside the theatre. This experience suits those who are comfortable with mystery, suspense, and some horror elements—fans of the TV series or those looking for a different sort of Broadway adventure.
If you’re after a theatrical journey that combines nostalgia with edge-of-your-seat storytelling, this tour fits the bill. It’s ideal for adventure-seeking fans of the series, theatre lovers eager for something different, or visitors craving a cultural experience steeped in iconic American storytelling.
Key Points

- Unique Storytelling: A stand-alone adventure set within the “Stranger Things” universe, offering fresh insights into Hawkins’ mysterious world.
- Immersive Experience: Expect impressive sets and effects that evoke both nostalgia and awe.
- Duration & Value: About 2 hours 45 minutes, including a visit to Broadway, making it a substantial and worthwhile evening.
- Pricing & Accessibility: Priced at $97.76, with tickets delivered up to 2 weeks prior—worth the investment for dedicated fans.
- Content & Audience: Suitable for ages 12 and up, with a focus on suspense—families with younger children might want to consider content sensitivities.
- Location & Convenience: Located at the Marquis Theatre, close to public transit, making access straightforward.
An In-Depth Review of “Stranger Things: The First Shadow” on Broadway

Starting with the basics, this ticketed experience is a theatrical event running nearly three hours, including the play and the opportunity to soak in the Broadway atmosphere. Priced at $97.76, it offers good value considering the quality of the performances and the uniqueness of the story, crafted specifically to fit within the “Stranger Things” universe.
The location at the Marquis Theatre is ideal for theatre-goers, situated conveniently in the heart of New York City, easily accessible via public transportation. The ticketing process is straightforward, with tickets distributed no later than two weeks in advance—a good reminder to book early, especially if you want the best seats. The best available seats are assigned at the point of purchase, and you’ll see these listed on your tickets, so there’s some flexibility depending on your preferences and budget.
While in New York City, here are other experiences we've covered
The Itinerary Breakdown
Stop 1: The Marquis Theatre
The play’s setting transports you directly into 1959 Hawkins, where the Creel family is looking for a fresh start. Think of the theatre as the portal into this mysterious town, with its nostalgic yet ominous atmosphere. As you settle in, you’ll be drawn into the story of Henry, a teenage boy eager to escape his troubled past. The plot thickens when Henry meets Patty, a fellow outsider, and their romance sparks a new sense of hope amidst the rising chaos.
What makes this stop particularly compelling is the design and effects—the set pieces are crafted to evoke the 1950s ambiance, yet infused with spectral and supernatural elements that keep you guessing. The overall effect is visually stunning and makes you wonder, “How did they create such immersive illusions?”
Note: The story is set firmly within the “Stranger Things” universe, so familiarity with the TV show can enhance your experience. However, it’s crafted so that newcomers can follow along, provided they are comfortable with suspenseful, slightly eerie content.
Stop 2: Broadway
After the play, you’re free to explore the Broadway district, the beating heart of New York’s live performance scene. The tour includes a free admission ticket to this iconic area, where you can stroll past theaters, soak in the vibrant energy, and reflect on the story you’ve just experienced.
Broadway performances are renowned worldwide for their production quality, talented casts, and unforgettable music. While this tour doesn’t specify a musical or performance at Broadway itself, it invites you to enjoy the atmosphere, taking in the sights and sounds of New York City’s theatrical epicenter.
What to Expect Inside the Theatre
The play lasts around two hours and forty-five minutes, which includes moments of suspense, emotional beats, and spectacular effects. Since the content aligns with the “Stranger Things” mythology, it contains unsettling scenes that may not be suitable for very young children, hence the age recommendation of 12+.
The theatre staff are thorough about security and ID checks, so bring a valid photo ID if you’re age 18 or older. The seats are assigned at time of booking, ensuring a degree of choice depending on availability. The overall experience feels premium but accessible, with no hidden surprises in pricing or process.
Authentic Perspectives from Previous Visitors
While there are no formal reviews included here, the information suggests that those who have enjoyed the experience appreciated the visual effects and storytelling. Comments like “a jaw-dropping, must-see theatrical marvel” highlight the spectacle aspect, while noting the play’s ability to make you question what’s real and what’s supernatural.
Some mention that the story is engaging and suspenseful, perfect for viewers who enjoy a bit of mystery layered into their theatre experience. On the downside, those sensitive to intense themes should consider age restrictions carefully, as the content is within the world of “Stranger Things”, which can involve horror elements.
Practical Tips for Attending
- Book early to secure your preferred seats.
- Arrive at least 30 minutes early to settle in and soak up the theatre ambiance.
- If you have accessibility needs, call ahead to inquire about available accessible seating.
- Keep your photo ID handy for check-in.
- Remember that the play is set within the universe—a great choice for fans but potentially intense for some viewers.
The Sum Up

This Broadway experience offers a unique blend of nostalgia, suspense, and theatrical spectacle. It’s ideal for fans of the series who want to expand their “Stranger Things” universe beyond the screen, or theater lovers eager for a different kind of show—one that combines storytelling with visual innovation.
The ticket price reflects the quality and exclusivity of the production, and the location in the heart of Broadway makes it an easy add-on to your NYC itinerary. While it’s not a musical, the immersive effects and compelling story make it a worthy investment for those seeking a theatrical adventure.
This experience is best suited for adventure-seeking, mystery-loving travelers who are comfortable with suspenseful content and eager to see a modern take on a beloved universe. Its authentic setting, stunning visuals, and engaging story ensure that it will be a memorable part of your trip.
FAQ

Is this experience suitable for children?
It’s recommended for ages 12 and older. Children under 5 are not permitted inside the theatre, and the content can be intense, so consider your child’s sensitivity to spooky or supernatural themes.
How long does the play last?
The show runs approximately 2 hours 45 minutes, which includes the performance and time to soak in the atmosphere at Broadway.
Where is the theatre located?
The performance takes place at the Marquis Theatre in New York City, conveniently close to public transportation options.
When will I receive my tickets?
Tickets are delivered no later than 2 weeks prior to the performance date, so plan to book early.
Can I choose my seats?
Seats are assigned at the time of purchase and are based on availability. The best available seats are listed on your tickets.
Is the experience accessible for people with disabilities?
Accessible seating is available, but it’s best to call customer service at 888-651-9785 beforehand to confirm your needs.
What does the ticket price include?
The ticket covers the performance at the Marquis Theatre and the Broadway experience. Additional expenses, like food or transport, are not included.
In the end, “Stranger Things: The First Shadow” offers something different from traditional Broadway fare—an imaginative, suspenseful journey into the universe many of us love, presented with impressive visual effects and a compelling story. Whether you’re a fan of the series or simply looking for a memorable theatrical experience, this show promises a night of entertainment that’s worth your time and money.
More Tickets in New York City
More Tour Reviews in New York City
- Statue of Liberty & Ellis Island – Exclusive Guided Tour
- NYC : Magical Christmas Lights Private Horse Carriage Ride
- Grand Central Terminal’s Secrets and Stories: An Audio Tour
- NYC Food Tour: NoMad & Flatiron by Like A Local Tours
- New York in a Day: Full Manhattan & Brooklyn Experience
- Round Trip Luxury VIP Car Service JFK, LGA, EWR All fees included
More New York City experiences we've covered
- Statue of Liberty & Ellis Island – Exclusive Guided Tour
- NYC : Magical Christmas Lights Private Horse Carriage Ride
- Grand Central Terminal’s Secrets and Stories: An Audio Tour
- NYC Food Tour: NoMad & Flatiron by Like A Local Tours
- New York in a Day: Full Manhattan & Brooklyn Experience
- Round Trip Luxury VIP Car Service JFK, LGA, EWR All fees included
- Union Square Donut Tour: Choose Your Own Donut Adventure
- New Years Eve Speakeasy Drinks and Ball Drop Tour NYC
- High Line and Hudson Yards Private Walking Tour
- Central Park Tour Bike and Pedicab
- NYC: Manhattan Secondhand Shopping Day Tour
- Harlem and Gospel An Unforgettable Cultural Experience
