Kelleys Island offers a rich mix of outdoor activities that bring you face-to-face with its rugged shoreline, glacial formations, and natural beauty. It’s not just about taking in the views; these tours are about getting your hands dirty, your feet moving, and your curiosity satisfied. We especially love the Kelleys Island Kayak Treasure Tour, which combines kayaking with a bit of island lore, wildlife spotting, and fossil hunting—perfect for those wanting an active, educational experience. Whether paddling along North Bay or exploring the Alvar Preserve, you’re bound to learn something new and see parts of the island that few visitors get to experience.
If you prefer exploring on land, the Hike and Bike Kelleys Island Trails offers a scenic, guided way to traverse the island’s varied habitats. Or, for a memorable end to your day, the Sunset Kayak Tour delivers peaceful waters, wildlife glimpses, and a stunning sunset—all in a private setting. Below, we dive into each of these top-rated tours, highlighting what makes them special and helping you decide which fits your style.
1. Kelleys Island Kayak Treasure Tour
At number one is the Kelleys Island Kayak Treasure Tour, a perfect blend of exploration, wildlife, and geology. This 2-hour private tour takes you around North Bay, where your guide will share the island’s stories while you paddle past beaches, rock piers, ponds, and preserves. For a small fee of $65 per person, you’ll receive all the necessary gear, making it easy for first-timers or seasoned kayakers alike.
What sets this tour apart is the focus on finding fossils and glacial erratics, which are surprisingly engaging even if you’re not a geology buff. Kids and adults rave about the opportunity to spot wildlife from the water, from waterfowl to fish, and the chance to take a quick swim in the refreshing waters. Dawn, one of the guides, has been described as knowledgeable about the island’s ecology and history, and her enthusiasm makes the experience memorable. The trip is flexible, with two tour times to fit your schedule, and the private setting ensures personalized attention.
Bottom line: This tour is ideal for active travelers, families, or anyone interested in combining physical activity with nature and history lessons. If you want a hands-on, small-group adventure that covers multiple habitats and geology, this one’s hard to beat.
2. Hike and Bike Kelleys Island Trails
Coming in at number two is the Hike and Bike Kelleys Island Trails, a guided exploration that balances physical activity with learning. For $40 per person, you’ll spend roughly two hours discovering the island’s top natural sights, starting at the iconic Glacial Grooves—where 270-foot deep marks reveal the power of Ice Age glaciers. The tour continues through Kelleys Island State Park, exploring off-road trails, and moves on to East Quarry, where different habitats thrive.
This tour shines because of its variety: biking along scenic trails, hiking through different environments, and stopping at key points for manageable 15- to 45-minute explorations. The guide will share insights about the formation of the glacial grooves and the island’s geological past, giving you a richer understanding of this unique landscape. All equipment is provided, and the small group size ensures you get personalized attention and plenty of opportunities to ask questions.
Guests praise the guide’s knowledge, with one reviewer noting, “She knows the island in and out and makes it very detailed,” and others mentioning how comfortable and fun the bikes are. It’s a flexible, active way to see the island’s natural highlights without needing prior experience.
Bottom line: Perfect for outdoor lovers who want a mix of biking, hiking, and education, this tour offers a dynamic way to explore the island’s most scenic and geologically interesting spots.
3. Sunset Kayak Tour
Rounding out the top three is the Sunset Kayak Tour, a serene, private paddle to watch the sun dip below Lake Erie. For $65 per person, you’ll spend about two hours gliding along the North Bay and the rugged, pristine shoreline of West Bay, known for its rocky terrain and quiet wildlife. Designed for smaller groups or families, this tour offers flexibility with booking times most days of the week.
The highlight is paddling in the most untouched part of the island, often seeing wildlife like herons, ducks, and perhaps even a glimpse of fish or turtles. The guide will assist in identifying animals and provide insights into the local ecosystem. Once the paddle is complete, your shuttle will return you to your starting point, making it a convenient, one-way experience. Many reviewers describe it as a “great experience” with plenty of wildlife sightings during the peaceful evening hours.
This tour is best suited for those wanting a relaxing, scenic experience in a small, private setting. It’s ideal for couples, families, or anyone looking to enjoy nature at sunset — a perfect way to unwind after a day of island exploration.
Bottom line: If you’re after tranquil waters, wildlife encounters, and a memorable sunset, this paddle is a wonderful choice, especially for those who prefer a personalized, quiet outing.
How to Choose the Best Tour for You
When deciding between these Kelleys Island adventures, consider your interests and physical condition. If you’re eager to combine activity with fossils and wildlife, the kayak treasure tour hits the spot. If you’d rather see the island’s natural habitats on foot or bike, the hiking and biking tour provides a broader exploration of the landscape. For a peaceful, end-of-day experience with stunning views, the sunset kayak offers a relaxing paddle without the need for intense activity.
Budget-wise, these tours are quite comparable, with prices ranging from $40 to $65, making them accessible options for most travelers. Think about your preferred pace and whether you want more educational content or leisure. Booking in advance is recommended, especially during peak season, to secure your preferred times.
Final Thoughts
Kelleys Island offers a variety of outdoor tours that bring you closer to its rugged coastlines, glacial features, and wildlife. For active travelers or families seeking educational fun, the Kayak Treasure Tour offers a hands-on experience with fossils, geology, and wildlife. If you enjoy scenic routes and learning about the island’s formation, the Hike and Bike Trails deliver in both adventure and insight. Lastly, for those seeking a tranquil end to the day, the Sunset Kayak Tour provides peace, stunning scenery, and a chance to see wildlife in the soft glow of evening light.
No matter which you choose, booking early is wise, especially during the busy summer months. Each tour provides a different way to see and experience Kelleys Island—so pick one that matches your style and make the most of your visit to this unique Lake Erie escape.