Turtles, Pizza Pi & Sunset trip

A Review of the Turtles, Pizza Pi & Sunset Trip in St. Thomas

Imagine sailing from the lively port of St. Thomas to the scenic shores of St. John, with the warm sea breeze in your hair and the promise of underwater adventures ahead. This 6-hour small-group tour, offered at $295 per person, centers around snorkeling, marine life encounters, a floating pizza restaurant, and sunset views. Led by guides like Jackson, Sierra, and John, the trip is packed with memorable moments, from swimming among turtles to savoring pizza delivered by the world’s only floating pizzeria.

What makes this experience special are two things we really appreciate: the intimate group size (limited to 12 guests), which fosters a relaxed environment, and the high-quality snorkeling gear included — no need to rent or worry about bringing your own. Plus, on-board mimosas, light snacks, and pizza add a fun, laid-back vibe to the trip.

The only potential drawback? The tour is weather-dependent, and if the seas turn choppy or the weather turns poor, the activity could be canceled. That’s rare, but it’s worth keeping in mind if you’re planning around unpredictable weather.

This trip suits travelers seeking a balanced mix of sailing, snorkeling, and relaxation, especially those who love marine life or enjoy a good laid-back cruise with plenty of opportunities to see turtles, sting rays, and even dolphins. Families, couples, or solo travelers who appreciate small groups and authentic experience will find this tour particularly appealing.

Key Points

• Intimate Group Size: Limited to 12 guests, ensuring a relaxed, personalized experience.
• Snorkeling & Marine Life: Excellent opportunities to see turtles, sting rays, and colorful fish.
• Floating Pizza: Unique lunch experience from the world’s only floating pizza restaurant, Pizza Pi VI.
• Scenic Sailing: Pass by Cinnamon Bay and Trunk Bay, with stunning views of the North Shore.
• All-Inclusive Beverages & Equipment: On-board mimosas, snacks, and snorkeling gear included.
• Weather Flexibility: Cancellations are possible in poor weather, but must be rebooked or refunded.

An In-Depth Look at the Experience

Starting Point and Duration

The tour kicks off at American Yacht Harbor in St. Thomas, a convenient spot reachable by taxi or nearby public transport. The trip lasts approximately 6 hours, making it a substantial half-day escape, perfect for those wanting to make the most of their time without feeling rushed. Guides like Jackson and Sierra are praised for their friendliness and knowledge, setting the tone for a fun and informative day.

The First Stop: Christmas Cove

The anchor drops in Christmas Cove, renowned for its protected waters and vibrant marine life. This calm spot is ideal for snorkeling, especially for beginners or those wanting a relaxed swim. Reviewers rave about the amazing visibility and the large number of turtles, with Jan_D noting “10+ Turtles, Dolphins, an Eagle Ray, and big Starfish.” The water here is warm and inviting, making it easy to forget about the world above.

And let’s not forget the pizza delivery: the floating pizzeria, Pizza Pi VI, drops off freshly made pizza by dinghy, adding a quirky touch. Some reviewers mention the pizza isn’t gourmet, but it’s still very satisfying when you’re hungry. One guest, Scott_N, said, “Pizza pie wasn’t very good pizza, but that’s not stormy pirates fault. Any pizza is still ok when you’re hungry.”

Passing Cinnamon Bay and Trunk Bay

As the boat sails along the North Shore of St. John, you’ll enjoy views of Cinnamon Bay and Trunk Bay—two of the Caribbean’s most photographed beaches. While most of the focus is on snorkeling and marine life, these sights are worth noting for their iconic beauty and perhaps a quick glance during the sail.

The Main Event: Maho Bay

The highlight for many is the stop at Maho Bay Beach, described by reviewers as one of the most beautiful beaches in the world. Here, the focus is on swimming with sea turtles and sting rays. Expect to spend about an hour at this tranquil spot, where the shallow waters make snorkeling a breeze. Several guests, including Ellen_R, describe it as “breathtaking,” with sightings of dolphins, eagle rays, and starfish.

What to Expect in the Water

The guides are praised for their helpfulness and attentiveness. Carly and Kevin, for example, were commended for their knowledgeable and friendly approach, making sure everyone felt comfortable. Some reviews highlight their efforts to check in on guests and provide tips for better snorkeling. The equipment, including snorkel masks and fins, is provided, ensuring you don’t need to bring your own gear.

Food and Drinks on Board

The on-board open bar is an appreciated touch, with light snacks and freshly brewed coffee in the morning. The pizza, served during the trip, is a fun and tasty addition—more about comfort and fun than gourmet dining. Many travelers mention how the crew, like Sierra and Dalton, kept drinks flowing and made sure everyone was comfortable, especially those prone to seasickness.

Crew and Atmosphere

The crew’s role is multifaceted—sailing safely, serving drinks, and sharing island stories. Multiple reviews highlight guides like Captain John, Sierra, Mason, and Jackson for their knowledge, friendliness, and ability to foster a relaxed atmosphere. The size of the group—often only a handful of guests—allows for a more personalized experience. While some guests like Elsa_D noted a less positive interaction with crew members, the vast majority describe the staff as enthusiastic, helpful, and genuinely caring.

Sunset Sail and Final Moments

The tour is designed to end with breathtaking sunset views—a perfect time to unwind and reflect on the day. Though some reviews don’t focus on the sunset, the overall sense of peace and beauty at the journey’s end is a recurring theme.

The Value in Context

At $295 per person, this tour offers a good balance of value and memorable experiences. The small-group size means more time in the water and less crowding, which enhances the feeling of genuine adventure. Snorkeling equipment plus all drinks and pizza included provides a hassle-free experience—no hidden costs or surprises.

Compared to larger, more commercial excursions, this trip feels more laid-back and authentic, with guides who genuinely love sharing their knowledge. Travelers consistently rave about the marine life sightings, especially the sea turtles, which are often the highlight. The combination of sailing, snorkeling, and relaxing makes this a great choice for those wanting more than just a boat ride.

Considerations

While most guests praise the experience, Elsa_D’s review reminds us that weather can impact the trip. Seas can be choppy, and some might find it uncomfortable, especially if prone to seasickness. Also, the pizza may not satisfy food connoisseurs, but it hits the spot for many. If you’re sensitive to sea conditions or picky about food, it’s worth keeping these points in mind.

Who Should Book This Trip?

This tour is ideal for marine life enthusiasts, families with kids, couples seeking a romantic day, or anyone who appreciates small-group, relaxed sailing adventures. If you love the idea of snorkeling among turtles and rays, enjoying a floating pizza lunch, and ending the day with a sunset, this experience ticks all those boxes. It’s especially suited for travelers who prioritize authentic, memorable experiences over large crowds or luxury dining.

The Sum Up

The Turtles, Pizza Pi & Sunset trip in the US Virgin Islands offers a well-rounded, laid-back taste of island life. With knowledgeable guides, stunning marine encounters, and the novelty of dining from a floating pizzeria, it embodies the spirit of casual Caribbean adventure. The small-group setting fosters a sense of camaraderie and intimacy, making it ideal for those who want to connect with the water and the natural beauty around them.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned island hopper, this tour delivers on authenticity, fun, and memorable sights. The combination of sailing, snorkeling, delicious food, and sunset views makes for a rich, rewarding day that’s worth every penny. Just remember, if weather turns unfavorable, the trip might be canceled, so it’s wise to keep your plans flexible.

For anyone longing for a relaxing day full of marine encounters and Caribbean charm, this tour is a smart pick. It’s a chance to unwind, see turtles and rays up close, and enjoy the laid-back vibe that makes the Virgin Islands so special.

FAQ

What is the duration of the tour?
The entire experience lasts around 6 hours, providing ample time to snorkel, sail, and relax without feeling rushed.

Where does the tour start and end?
The trip begins at American Yacht Harbor in Red Hook, St. Thomas, and returns to the same location at the end of the day.

Is snorkeling gear provided?
Yes, all snorkeling equipment is included, so you don’t need to bring your own gear.

What is included in the price?
The cost covers snorkeling equipment, lunch (pizza from Pizza Pi VI), an open bar, light snacks, restroom facilities, and the crew’s services.

Are there any age restrictions?
Most travelers can participate, and service animals are allowed. The reviews mention family groups, so it’s suitable for children and adults alike.

What should I wear or bring?
Bring swimwear, a towel, sunscreen, and perhaps a hat or sunglasses for sun protection. The boat provides snorkel gear and drinks.

Is there a minimum number of participants?
Yes, the tour requires enough guests to operate, but it often runs with only a handful of people, making it very intimate.

Can I cancel if the weather is bad?
Yes, the tour is weather-dependent. If canceled, you’ll be offered a different date or a full refund.

Do I need to tip the crew?
Gratuity is not included but is customary at about 20% of the trip price if you feel the crew provided excellent service.

This adventure offers a delightful blend of sailing, wildlife, and delicious casual dining. Perfect for those wanting a memorable and authentic Virgin Islands experience, with the bonus of relaxed guides and stunning scenery.