Torrid Tales of St. Augustine: True Crime Walking Tour

Imagine wandering through the historic streets of St. Augustine, Florida, at dusk, feeling a shiver as the stories of its darker side unfold. This 1.5-hour guided walking tour offers a glimpse into the town’s most infamous crimes, from nearly 240 years ago to recent, debated cases caught on tape. For just $30 per person, you’re led by a knowledgeable guide—whose name might be Nick, based on reviews—and taken on a journey that combines history, mystery, and a touch of the macabre.

What we love most about this tour is the close-up experience of walking the actual crime scenes, which makes the stories linger longer in your mind. The second highlight? The ability to see photos and images of perpetrators and victims that bring the stories to life. This visual element adds a layer of authenticity and emotional impact that many guided tours lack.

A potential consideration is that some of the streets are old and uneven, so comfortable footwear is a must. Also, since this is a true crime tour, the content can be quite graphic or disturbing, which might not suit everyone.

Ultimately, this tour is perfect for history buffs, true crime enthusiasts, and anyone curious about the darker tales hidden within St. Augustine’s charming façade. If you’re looking for an experience that’s both educational and slightly unsettling, this tour checks all those boxes.

• Authentic experience walking the actual crime scenes of historic St. Augustine
• Insightful stories with detailed case information, some recent and some centuries old
• Visual aids including images of victims and perpetrators, making the stories more tangible
• Flexibility to discuss cases further inside a local bar after the tour
• Family-friendly warning: Not suitable for children under 15 due to the nature of content
• Wheelchair accessible and available in the evening, adding convenience for most travelers

What Makes This Tour Stand Out

This true crime walking tour is a rare mix of history, storytelling, and local lore. Unlike typical sightseeing walks that focus solely on architecture or landmarks, this experience zeroes in on the stories behind the crimes, some of which remain unsolved or debated even today.

Led by a guide who shares engaging, detailed accounts, you’ll walk the same streets where these crimes occurred. The focus on both old cases, dating back nearly 240 years, and recent events caught on tape offers a comprehensive look at how crime shaped the city’s dark side.

You can check availability for your dates here:

The Itinerary and Stops

The tour begins on the street side of the parking lot for Pizzalleys. From there, expect to stroll through several historic streets, each with its own story to tell. While the exact stops aren’t specified, the focus is on locating the scenes of murders, places where victims were last seen, and notorious crime sites.

One highlight is seeing the location of a recent, heated debate over a crime captured on tape—a case that still sparks discussion among locals and visitors alike. Throughout, images of the perpetrators and victims are shared, making the stories more visceral.

You might find that some stories are gripping and well-researched, while others leave you questioning if justice was truly served. The tour encourages you to decide for yourself whether the right person was convicted or if some cases remain unresolved.

The Experience and Atmosphere

Walking at night (or in the evening) adds an extra layer of atmosphere, making the dark streets feel more intense. The tour’s pace is leisurely enough to allow listening, reflection, and discussion.

The guide is described as engaging and knowledgeable, often sharing references and images that give depth to each story. Some reviews mention “chilling” moments and a sense of suspense that keeps you on edge.

Post-Tour Discussion and Atmosphere

After the walk, you’ll end outside a local bar, where you can continue discussing the stories over a drink. This offers a friendly, informal setting to share impressions or ask further questions.

This informal ending is a nice touch, offering an opportunity to connect with other history buffs and reflect on what you’ve learned. However, note that alcohol and drugs are not allowed during the tour itself, maintaining focus and safety.

Practical Details and Value

At $30 per person, the tour offers solid value, especially considering the included images and reference materials. The 1.5-hour duration makes it a manageable addition to your evening without being overly demanding.

Reservations are flexible—you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund—and booking is simple, with the option to pay later to keep your plans flexible. The tour is wheelchair accessible and typically available during the evening, fitting well into most schedules.

If you enjoy true crime stories, especially those woven into local history, this tour is a perfect fit. It’s also great for history fans who want a different perspective on St. Augustine, beyond the usual colonial sights.

Since it’s not suitable for children under 15, it’s best suited for adults or teenagers interested in the darker side of history. The detailed stories, visuals, and discussions make it an engaging experience for curious travelers who like a combination of education and entertainment.

This Torrid Tales of St. Augustine tour offers a unique glimpse into the town’s more sinister side. It’s a well-structured, engaging experience that combines storytelling, visual aids, and walking through the actual crime scenes. Its moderate price and small-group feel make it a good value for those seeking a more authentic, immersive experience.

This tour excels in turning history into stories that make you think about justice, morality, and the human condition. The chance to discuss cases afterwards in a relaxed setting adds to its appeal, making it more than just a walk—it’s a chance to reflect and connect.

Whether you’re a true crime enthusiast, history lover, or just curious about the darker stories behind St. Augustine’s picturesque streets, this tour offers a memorable, slightly eerie experience that you won’t forget.

Is this tour suitable for children?
No, it’s not recommended for children under 15 due to the mature and potentially disturbing nature of the crime stories.

How long does the tour last?
The tour lasts approximately 1.5 hours, making it a concise but engaging experience.

Where does the tour start?
It begins on the street side of the parking lot for Pizzalleys restaurant/Chianti Room, across from Aviles Restaurant.

Is the tour accessible for travelers with mobility issues?
Yes, it is wheelchair accessible, but keep in mind the streets are old and uneven, so comfortable footwear is advised.

What’s included in the price?
The tour includes a guided walk, true crime stories, references, images, and the opportunity to discuss cases further after the walk in a local bar.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, offering flexibility for your travel plans.

Are there any restrictions on drinks or alcohol?
Yes, alcohol and drugs are not allowed during the tour to ensure safety and focus.

This tour offers a compelling, authentic look at the darker stories hidden within St. Augustine, making it a memorable addition for those wanting a different kind of historic experience.

You can check availability for your dates here: