New York: Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live

Imagine stepping into a small, lively venue just steps from Times Square, where some of the funniest comedians in the country are ready to make you laugh until your cheeks hurt. For just $25 per person, you can enjoy 1.5 hours of stand-up comedy featuring acts seen on Netflix, Hulu, and Saturday Night Live. The Broadway Comedy Club offers a genuine New York comedy experience, complete with surprise guest comics dropping in nightly. It’s an exciting, affordable option for anyone wanting to see high-quality comedy in an intimate setting.

What we really love about this experience is how close the seats are to the stage—no awkward back rows here. Plus, the lineup is often made up of comics from major TV shows and comedy platforms, meaning you’re getting professional, polished humor. On the down side, expect a two-drink minimum (which is standard but can add up), and be prepared that comedians may vary in style and material. Overall, if you’re looking for a fun, lively night with top comics in a relaxed environment, this show hits the mark. It’s especially perfect for adults who enjoy comedy and don’t mind the expense of drinks.

Key Points

• Intimate Venue: All seats are close to the stage, creating a personal and engaging experience.
• TV-Featured Comedians: Acts include comedians seen on Netflix, Hulu, and Saturday Night Live.
• Location Advantage: Near Times Square and the Broadway Theater District, ideal for combining with other NYC sights.
• Two Drink Minimum: Expect to purchase at least two drinks—both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options are available.
• Surprise Drop-ins: Expect the unexpected with guest comedians dropping in nightly.
• Good Value: With tickets at $25 and a 1.5-hour duration, it’s an affordable way to enjoy top-tier comedy.

You can check availability for your dates here:

The Venue and Location

The Broadway Comedy Club is tucked near the hustle of Times Square, making it an easy addition to any evening plans in Midtown Manhattan. Its intimate size means every seat offers a clear view of the stage, fostering a feeling that you’re part of the action rather than just an observer. As many reviews highlight, the close proximity to the performers is a big plus—“all seats are close to the stage,” as one reviewer put it, making the humor more immediate and engaging.

The venue itself has a relaxed, no-frills vibe. Some reviews mention that the appearance of the venue could use some sprucing up, but the focus remains on the comedy and the audience experience. It’s clear that the venue prioritizes the quality of the acts over glitzy décor, which many patrons appreciate.

The Lineup and Performers

One of the biggest draws of this show is the high caliber of comedians. Many acts are seen on Netflix, Hulu, Comedy Central, and other major platforms—“the best comedians from New York City” with special guests from across the country. Audience members consistently praise the professionalism and humor of the performers, with some describing the opening acts as “amazing” and “a treat”.

The lineup is dynamic, with surprise guests dropping in nightly, adding an element of unpredictability. However, it’s worth noting that individual comedian appearances may vary without notice, so you might see a different show each time.

The Comedy Style and Atmosphere

The casual, laid-back atmosphere is one of the venue’s strengths. As one review noted, it’s perfect for adults who want to unwind and laugh. The audience participation is part of the charm—sometimes a drunk lady or a stage crash—that can make the night even more memorable. Although some humor may be edgy or rely on dialects that are difficult to follow for some, overall, the level of comedy is high.

The comedians’ styles vary, from some who are more established to those still honing their craft. This mix is appreciated by many, with one reviewer noting, “some made me laugh more than others, but overall a good night.” The “brilliant comedians” and “learning their trade” performers make for a lively, authentic experience.

The Practicalities: Price, Duration, and Drinks

At $25 per ticket, the show is quite affordable considering the quality of the acts. The duration of 1.5 hours strikes a good balance—long enough to get your money’s worth but not so long that it drags.

Two drinks are required—both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options are available—and this can be a positive or a drawback. Many reviews mention that drinks can be expensive, with $11 for a bottle of Stella being a common complaint. Still, the two-drink minimum is standard for comedy clubs and can be seen as part of the authentic NYC comedy experience.

The venue is wheelchair accessible, making it inclusive for all guests. Entry is straightforward—simply present your confirmation at the box office, and you’re good to go. You can enter up to 30 minutes before the show, giving you a chance to settle in and soak up the little pre-show excitement.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Experience and What to Expect

Expect a vibrant, energetic environment. The comedy lineup often includes comedians you’ve seen on TV, which is a major plus for fans of stand-up. The surprise guest drop-ins add an element of spontaneity, keeping every show fresh.

From the reviews, we know that the audience’s reactions can sometimes be part of the entertainment—some patrons have described “hilarious” moments with unruly audience members or unexpected interruptions. This casual vibe makes for a laid-back night, good for those who enjoy a bit of unpredictability.

The seating arrangements can be somewhat crowded, with some guests mentioning they were twisted sideways to the stage—not ideal for those who prefer more space, but manageable for most. The overall atmosphere is friendly and informal, which suits travelers looking for a fun night out without pretense.

Authenticity and Real Experiences

Many travelers praise the authenticity of the comedy. As one UK reviewer states, “The first three comedians were amazing and had me laughing”, and another comments on the variety of comedy styles—some more polished, others still learning the craft. The good mix of new and experienced comedians ensures a lively, unpredictable show.

While some mention that the drinks are expensive, they also acknowledge the good value for the ticket price. The comedians’ talent and TV appearances make this a worthwhile outing, especially if you appreciate professional comedy in a cozy setting.

Suitability and Recommendations

This experience is best suited for adults who love comedy and enjoy lively, informal environments. It’s not ideal for children under 12, given the adult humor and potential for unruly moments. It’s a great choice for couples, groups of friends, or solo travelers looking to round out their NYC night with a fun, memorable show.

If you’re a comedy aficionado or simply want a relaxed night with some of the best local and national comics, this club offers real value. Just keep in mind the drink minimum and the variability of performers—but in New York, that’s part of the charm.

The Broadway Comedy Club provides a genuine, affordable slice of NYC comedy. Its intimate setting and talented lineup make it stand out as a memorable night in the city that never sleeps. While the drinks may be pricey and the venue a bit basic, the caliber of comedians and the lively atmosphere more than compensate.

This experience is perfect for those who want to see top comics, enjoy a relaxed environment, and don’t mind spending a bit on drinks. If you’re in Manhattan and craving a night filled with laughter, this is a solid choice. It offers a true taste of New York’s comedy scene—unpretentious, lively, and full of surprises.

Is the show suitable for children?
No, the show is not recommended for children under 12 due to adult content and humor.

How long does the show last?
The performance runs approximately 1.5 hours, sometimes up to 10 minutes longer.

Do I need to buy drinks?
Yes, each guest is required to purchase at least two drinks—alcoholic or non-alcoholic—due to the two-drink minimum policy.

Can I enter early?
Yes, you can enter up to 30 minutes before the performance begins for seating and settling in.

Are the comedians always the same?
No, the lineup varies, and surprise guest comedians often drop in, adding unpredictability.

Is the venue accessible?
Yes, the Brooklyn Comedy Club is wheelchair accessible.

What’s the ticket price?
Tickets are $25 per person, offering good value considering the top-tier comedy acts.

Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

Is it a good experience for comedy lovers?
Absolutely. The acts are seen on major platforms, and many reviews highlight the quality of humor.

Is there a dress code?
No formal dress code; casual attire is perfectly fine.

Whether you’re craving a night of laughs with top TV comedians, or just want to see live comedy in a friendly, unpretentious setting, Broadway Comedy Club is a solid pick. Just remember to bring a sense of humor—and maybe a little extra for drinks!

You can check availability for your dates here: