NYC: Stranger Things: The First Shadow on Broadway

Imagine stepping into the world of Hawkins, Indiana, in 1959, where familiar characters face new challenges and darker shadows loom. This stand-alone prequel to the popular Netflix series offers a chance to see how it all began — complete with breathtaking effects and a talented creative team. For a ticket price that’s quite reasonable considering the quality, you’ll spend roughly two hours (including a short intermission) in a theatre that promises both nostalgia and suspense.

What truly sets this show apart are its award-winning production — including two Olivier Awards, one for Best Entertainment — and the expertise of a top-notch creative team, led by director Stephen Daldry. We loved the stunning visuals and remarkably authentic performances that bring this alternate Hawkins era vividly to life. Plus, the show is brought to you by Netflix and Sonia Friedman Productions, ensuring a polished, professional experience.

A key consideration is that this production is not suitable for children under 11 — the story’s shadows and themes are darker, and the effects sometimes intense. If you’re after a lively, family-friendly musical, you might want to look elsewhere. But if you’re a fan of the series or appreciate high-quality theatre with a sci-fi twist, this show is likely to be a highlight of your Broadway visit.

This experience appeals most to those with a love for original storytelling and special effects. If you enjoy engaging plots with a bit of nostalgic flair, and don’t mind a slightly more intense theatrical atmosphere, you’ll find plenty to enjoy here.

Key Points

• Immersive Prequel: Explores the origins of the Stranger Things universe, set in 1959 Hawkins.
• Award-Winning Production: Recognized with two Olivier Awards, including Best Entertainment.
• Stunning Effects: Features advanced special effects that keep audiences on the edge of their seats.
• Talented Creative Team: Directed by Stephen Daldry, known for innovative and emotional theatre.
• Family Suitability: Not recommended for children under 11 due to themes and effects.
• Value for Money: Approximately 2 hours of high-quality entertainment, with positive reviews praising organization and performances.

You can check availability for your dates here:

A Deep Dive into the Experience

The Setting and Storyline

The setting of Hawkins in 1959 immediately transports you to a time when the town appears peaceful but is shrouded in secrets. The story revolves around a new student, Henry Creel, whose arrival disrupts the town’s delicate peace. We loved how the story portrays familiar characters like Jim Hopper, Joyce Maldonado (a nod to Joyce Byers in the series), and Bob Newby’s sister, giving us a glimpse of their lives before the series’ timeline.

The narrative’s focus on how the shadows of the past stretch into the future feels both nostalgic and fresh. It’s a stand-alone adventure, so you don’t need prior knowledge of the series, which makes it accessible for newcomers as well as long-time fans.

The Creative Team and Its Impact

At the helm is director Stephen Daldry, renowned for his work on The Crown and Billy Elliot. His touch is evident in the show’s balance of emotional depth and visual spectacle. Co-director Justin Martin also contributes to the dynamic pacing. The team’s acclaimed work translates into stunning stage effects and compelling performances that draw you into Hawkins’ mysterious world.

The Special Effects and Technical Aspects

One of the standout elements of this production is the impressive special effects. We loved the way the show utilizes lighting, sound, and physical effects to create supernatural shadows and otherworldly phenomena. Audience members from various reviews mention “really cool effects” and “stunning visuals”, making the supernatural elements believable and immersive.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Experience at the Marquis Theatre

Presented at the Marquis Theatre, your ticket simply needs to be shown at the entrance. The theatre’s intimate setting helps keep the story personal; you’ll feel close to the action, even amidst the larger-than-life effects. The duration includes one intermission, giving you a chance to stretch your legs and discuss the unfolding mystery.

Cost and Overall Value

Prices fluctuate based on availability, but considering the top-tier production quality and well-reviewed performances, the ticket cost offers excellent value. For about two hours of entertainment, you get a show that has earned praise globally, with “spectacular effects” and “very good actors” as some reviewers noted.

Practical Tips for Attendees

• Arrive early to avoid last-minute rush and find your seats comfortably.
• Remember, no smoking or flash photography during the show.
• Since the show is quite intense at times, consider your children’s sensitivity if you’re bringing young ones near the age limit.
• Food and drinks are not included, so plan accordingly—perhaps grab a snack before or after the show.

What Reviewers Really Think

Multiple attendees have lauded the production as “one of the best live shows” they’ve seen — a testament to its gripping storytelling and technical brilliance. Violeta from Switzerland called it “the hammer”, and Natalia from Germany said, “It was great, really cool effects and very good actors.” These glowing reviews highlight how well the show connects with audiences, whether through storytelling, visuals, or performances.

Who Will Love This Show?

If you’re a series fan, you’ll appreciate the backstory and nostalgic nods woven into the plot. Those who enjoy spectacular stage effects will be thrilled at the technical prowess on display. Fans of award-winning theatre will recognize the high craftsmanship, and even newcomers who enjoy mystery and supernatural themes will find this production engaging.

However, if you’re traveling with children under 11 or prefer a lighter, more family-friendly musical, this might not be your best choice. It’s best suited for those seeking a theatrical experience that combines story, spectacle, and a dark, intriguing atmosphere.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is the show?
Expect about two hours, including a brief intermission. The duration allows for a full, immersive experience without feeling overly long.

Are tickets difficult to get?
Prices depend on availability, so it’s wise to book early if possible. The show has a high rating and many positive reviews, indicating it’s popular among theatre-goers.

Is it suitable for children?
No, it’s not recommended for children under 11 due to dark themes and intense effects. For older kids and teens, use your judgment based on their sensitivity.

What makes the special effects stand out?
The production employs advanced lighting, sound, and physical effects to create supernatural phenomena that are both believable and theatrical, keeping viewers engaged and on the edge of their seats.

Who are the creative minds behind the show?
Director Stephen Daldry, known for Billy Elliot and The Crown, leads a talented team, ensuring a production that’s both emotionally compelling and visually spectacular.

How does this compare to other Broadway shows?
While musicals like The Lion King or Wicked focus on singing and dance, this show emphasizes special effects and storytelling, making it a different but equally captivating theatrical experience.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow on Broadway offers an exciting glimpse into the origins of the beloved series, wrapped in a high-quality theatrical package. Thanks to stunning effects, strong performances, and an engaging storyline, it provides more than just a visual spectacle — it’s a well-crafted piece of entertainment that keeps you guessing and invested.

For series fans, theatre aficionados, or anyone craving a dark, atmospheric story, this show delivers remarkable value. Its production quality and positive reviews suggest you’re in for an impressive night of theatre — one that blends nostalgia with innovation.

However, it’s important to remember that the intensity and themes may not suit younger children or sensitive viewers. If you’re prepared for a slightly darker, effects-heavy experience, you’ll find this a worthwhile addition to your Broadway adventures.

In sum, this production is worth considering if you seek top-tier entertainment with a supernatural twist in the heart of New York City. Book your tickets early, arrive prepared for an immersive experience, and enjoy a show that’s both spectacular and emotionally engaging.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Ready to explore more Broadway magic? Check out other popular shows like The Lion King or Wicked for a varied theatrical experience that complements this adventure in mystery and special effects.